I made pumpkin pie using 3 celebrity-chef recipes, and the worst was from a baking legend

Paige Bennett for InsiderA slice of each celebrity-chef pumpkin pie.
  • I made pumpkin pies using recipes from Dominique Ansel, Alton Brown, and Bobby Flay.
  • My favourite recipe was Flay’s because it was easy to follow and its special whipped cream was delicious.
  • Ansel’s recipe was a disaster to make, and the pie tasted quite bland.
  • Brown’s recipe was the simplest and had a stellar crust, but it didn’t blow me away.
  • Visit Insider’s homepage for more stories.

When it comes to fall comfort foods, nothing takes the cake quite like a slice of homemade pumpkin pie.

Celebrity chefs certainly feel the same way, which is why so many have their own pumpkin-pie recipes.

To find out which are worth trying, I tested pumpkin-pie recipes from Bobby Flay, Dominique Ansel, and Alton Brown.

Read on to see how the pies turned out.

Flay’s signature pumpkin-pie recipe has many steps

Bobby Flay ingredientsPaige Bennett for InsiderThe ingredients for Bobby Flay’s pumpkin pie.

Though he’s known as a grill master, Flay can throw down when it comes to pies.

His recipe on the Food Network’s website has several steps, but it seemed easy to organise and measure all the ingredients in advance.

The recipe also called for homemade bourbon-maple whipped cream, which sounded tasty. To make it, I needed grade-B syrup — but I learned that it no longer exists. So I stuck with grade A.

The pie came together easily and smelled delicious

Since I measured everything in advance, making the filling was as simple as pouring and whisking the ingredients together, then straining it for a super-smooth centre.

Bobby Flay process 4   mixing fillingPaige Bennett for InsiderMixing the ingredients was easy.

The only hiccup I had was that I don’t own a food processor. I used a small blender/food-chopper that didn’t quite work as well.

That made it tricky to integrate the melted butter with the crushed graham cracker.

Bobby Flay process 2   baking crustPaige Bennett for InsiderThe graham-cracker crust had to bake.

Overall, the hands-on part was quick and easy. After baking for 10 minutes, my crust was set and ready to be filled.

The recipe produced far more filling than I needed, so I froze the leftovers for a future pie.

Bobby Flay process 8   pouring fillingPaige Bennett for InsiderThe crust wasn’t perfect, but it held the filling just fine.

I baked the pie for about 90 minutes. It came out golden, with a flawless top — no cracks here!

The whipped cream and the pie went together perfectly

Bobby Flay final whole pie with whipped creamPaige Bennett for InsiderFlay’s pie looked perfect once it cooled.

I was impressed with how well the pie held its shape as I cut into it. Though the crust along the bottom was probably thicker than it should have been, I was happy it didn’t crumble and fall apart.

The whipped cream alone was incredibly delicious. I could taste every element: the cream, the vanilla, the bourbon, and the maple syrup.

As for the pie, the filling had a light pumpkin flavour with a nice balance of sweetness and spice. With the whipped cream, the dessert had the perfect balance of vanilla, maple syrup, warm pumpkin, and spices.

Bobby Flay final slice 1Paige Bennett for InsiderFlay’s pie looked smooth and delicious.

The graham-cracker crust was fine, but I wished it were crunchier — I was disappointed by its slightly soggy bottom.

The edges were crisp, but they weren’t as flavorful as I would have liked.

Ansel’s pumpkin-pie recipe is heavy on the ginger and calls for a dough crust

Dominique Ansel ingredientsPaige Bennett for InsiderThe ingredients for Dominique Ansel’s pumpkin pie.

I followed a recipe that the famous pastry chef and inventor of the cronut shared with InStyle.

My first concern was how much ginger — fresh and ground — it called for. I like ginger, but I don’t love it in large quantities.

I was also expecting the pie to have a pretty rich centre, since this recipe requires a lot of egg yolks for the filling.

For the crust, I had to battle with the dough

Since it involved making a dough-based crust, this recipe required a lot of steps. I’d recommend making this the day before if you need it for a certain occasion.

It took me a long time to grate the fresh ginger for the crust, so I ended up cutting the amount to about 1 1/2 tablespoons from 2 tablespoons.

After I mixed the crust ingredients and let it chill, it was time to roll. I cut the dough and put aside one half, which I originally planned to freeze for later.

Dominique Ansel process 2 dough ready to chillPaige Bennett for InsiderThe dough was incredibly difficult to roll.

But rolling the dough was a disaster. My first half kept sticking to the rolling pin and the surface even though I had put flour on them and my hands before I started.

I got frustrated and scrapped this half, thankful to still have the second half. I kept this dough loosely wrapped in plastic wrap to help prevent it from sticking to the rolling pin.

This worked somewhat well — until I had to peel the dough from the plastic wrap and it fell apart.

I wrangled the dough as best as I could and draped it over my pie dish. It didn’t quite fit, so I did my best to patch it together.

Dominique Ansel process 4 dough rolling disasterPaige Bennett for InsiderThe dough didn’t fit nicely in the pan.

Next was the blind bake — when you bake a pie crust before filling it — which made me nervous because of how delicate the dough was. I used parchment paper and dry rice to weigh down the crust as it baked.

When I pulled the crust out and removed the rice, most of my dough came up with it.

I scraped some of the paper off and mended the crust as best as I could, but this was turning out to be a disaster.

Dominique Ansel process 6 patched the crust upPaige Bennett for InsiderEventually I patched the dough together enough to form a crust.

I pressed on and added the filling to the crust anyway. Then it was ready to bake.

Dominique Ansel process 7 pouring fillingPaige Bennett for InsiderFortunately, the filling seemed pretty creamy.

The pie took about 20 minutes longer to bake than the recipe’s maximum estimated time of 35 minutes.

For all the trouble, the pie ended up rather bland

Dominique Ansel process 10 coolingPaige Bennett for InsiderThe pie I made with Ansel’s recipe was OK.

The pie looked OK coming out of the oven. The crust didn’t have a perfectly pinched edge, but at this point I was glad it came together at all.

The filling mushroomed above the crust while it was in the oven, then dropped near the end of baking, which led to several cracks around the pie.

I thought that this pie would hold its shape the best of all three recipes because it had a dough crust, but it fell apart when I cut a slice. The bottom crust was thicker on one side and slightly soggy.

Dominique Ansel final 2Paige Bennett for InsiderThe crust wasn’t great.

The pumpkin layer tasted strongly of pumpkin — I would have loved more sweetness and a bit more spice for a better flavour.

The texture was super smooth thanks to the yolks. Fortunately, the ginger didn’t overpower the flavour of the pie. But I wished the crust had more flavour.

For convenience, I swapped fresh pumpkin for canned in Brown’s recipe

Alton Brown ingredientsPaige Bennett for InsiderThe ingredients for Alton Brown’s pie.

Brown’s recipe on the Food Network’s website requires baking a fresh pumpkin to make homemade pumpkin purée. Short on time and not a fan of pumpkin guts, I skipped this and used canned pumpkin purée.

I was surprised to see that this recipe didn’t call for cinnamon, unlike any pumpkin pie I’ve ever made (or eaten). I hoped the nutmeg would make up for it.

Of the 3 recipes, Brown’s was the easiest to follow

The pie’s gingersnap crust was similar to Flay’s graham-cracker one. Without a food processor, it couldn’t come together as well as it should, but it still looked fine and smelled even better.

Alton Brown process 1 combining crustPaige Bennett for InsiderFor the crust, I used a small appliance to grind the cookies.

I pressed it into a pie dish and baked it for about 10 minutes.

Without fresh pumpkin, the filling was easy to make. I warmed the pumpkin purée and half-and-half along with nutmeg and salt on the stove, then whisked this mixture in a bowl with brown sugar and eggs.

I let the filling and the crust cool for 15 minutes, then combined them and baked my pie for 45 minutes.

Alton Brown process 6 pouring fillingPaige Bennett for InsiderThe filling for Brown’s pie was light orange.

There were no mishaps here; the process was straightforward and quick. Obviously, if I had made the pumpkin purée from scratch, it would have taken much longer.

I loved the flavour of the gingersnap crust

Alton Brown final 1Paige Bennett for InsiderBrown’s pie was looking pretty good.

After baking the pie, I noticed it had a bit of liquid pooling on the surface. Otherwise, the surface was blemish-free.

The sturdy crust held everything in place as I removed a slice from the pan.

The clear definition between crust and pumpkin in each slice made for a really nice presentation.

The filling could’ve used a bit more spice — cinnamon, perhaps — but it was still delicious. The pumpkin flavour came through and was sweet.

Alton Brown final 4Paige Bennett for InsiderBrown’s pie sliced quite evenly.

The ginger flavour in the crust came through in every bite. It was slightly soggier than I had hoped, even along the edges, but I was worried that much longer in the oven would have resulted in a burnt crust.

I’d definitely make Flay’s recipe again, especially the whipped cream

All pies 2, left to rightPaige Bennett for InsiderBrown’s pie (front), Flay’s pie (back), and Ansel’s pie (right).

I loved the filling and whipped cream from Flay’s recipe, and overall the pie was simple to put together. The only thing I would change is making the crust more flavorful, perhaps by adding spices.

Brown’s crust was delicious, and the filling’s texture was perfect. With a food processor, I think I could get the crust to have a better texture. This recipe resulted in a pie that looked as good on Instagram as it did in real life.

Truthfully, I would love to try Flay’s filling and whipped cream with Brown’s gingersnap crust for the ultimate pumpkin pie.

Unfortunately, I can’t see myself attempting Ansel’s recipe again.

Business Insider Emails & Alerts

Site highlights each day to your inbox.

Follow Business Insider Australia on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Instagram.