Warren Buffett says “our favourite holding period is forever” and yet he sold eight stocks during the fourth quarter of 2010. It was surprising that Berkshire hadn’t made any new purchases during the fourth quarter. Todd Combs must still be going through orientation. Why didn’t he buy at least some of the companies he held in his hedge fund?
Anyway, the star of this 13F filing isn’t Todd Combs. It’s Lou Simpson, who retired at the end of last year. It’s crystal clear that Warren Buffett made Lou Simpson sell all his stock picks. Buffett was probably never comfortable with Simpson’s stock picks, so he got rid of those stocks even if it meant changing his “Rule Number 4: Our favourite holding period is forever”. Here is how those 8 stocks performed:
Company Ticker 2011 Return Value (Millions) Bank of America BAC 10.7% 66 Becton Dickinson & Co. BDX -3.8% 140 Comcast Corp CMCSK 9.1% 3 Fiserv Inc FISV 6.5% 210 Lowes Companies Inc. LOW 0.5% 145 Nike Inc NKE 0.9% 292 Nalco Holding Co. NLC -14.4% 155 Nestle NSRGY -9.1% 182The weighted average return for Lou Simpson’s 8 stock picks were -1.7% since the end of 2010, vs. SPY’s 5.9%. So, Berkshire Hathaway investors avoided an underperformance of 7.6 percentage points for a total portfolio value of $1.2 Billion. Of course one shouldn’t judge the performance of a portfolio based on a few weeks’ performance. Insider Monkey, your source for free insider trading data, calculated Lou Simpson’s 2010 performance as well. These eight stocks had a weighted average return of 20.2% beating the S&P 500 index by 5 percentage points. The same portfolio had a 37.5% return in 2009, beating the S&P 500 index by more than 10 percentage points. These stocks lost 25.1% in 2008 and managed to beat the S&P 500 index again by more than 10 percentage points.
It’s clear that these were nicely picked stocks that managed to beat the market by a huge margin over the past 3 years. But why did Warren Buffett sell these stocks now? It seems Lou Simpson’s alpha is actually higher than the rest of Berkshire Hathaway’s stock pickers.
There were a few changes in Warren Buffett’s other holdings. He added 6.2 million shares of Wells Fargo (WFC). He also sold around 200,000 shares of Bank of New York Mellon (BK) and more than 450,000 shares of Moody’s (MCO).
Company Ticker Value (Million) Return Coca Cola KO 13154 -3.3% Wells Fargo WFC 10618 9.1% American Express AXP 6507 9.4% Procter & Gamble PG 4938 1.4% Kraft Foods Inc. KFT 3315 -2.7% Johnson & Johnson JNJ 2636 -1.9% Wal-Mart Stores Inc WMT 2105 3.3% Wesco Finl Corp. WSC 2101 5.4% ConocoPhillips COP 1982 5.1% US Bancorp USB 1862 1.8% Washington Post WPO 759 -1.8% Moody’s MCO 754 14.8% M & T Bank MTB 467 3.2% Costco Wholesale Corp COST 313 4.2% USG Corporation USG 287 13.5% Torchmark Corp. TMK 169 6.5% General Electric GE 142 16.6% Sanofi Aventis SNY 131 5.0% UPS UPS 104 4.5% GlaxoSmithKline GSK 59 -2.2% Bank of NY Mellon BK 54 6.8% Exxon Mobil XOM 31 13.9% Ingersoll-Rand Company IR 30 0.8% Gannett Inc. GCI 26 13.1% Comdisco Holding CDCO 14 -2.8%The weighted average return for Warren Buffett’s stock portfolio is 3.1% since the end of December, underperforming the SPY’s 5.9%. These stocks slightly underperformed the SPY both in 2009 and 2010. Previously we showed that Warren Buffett’s alpha was zero between 2000 and 2009. Over the past two years, Warren Buffett’s portfolio didn’t even manage to beat the SPY.