The US Supreme Court is hearing a 9-year-old case about Xbox

Phil Spencer XboxKevork Djansezian/Getty ImagesXbox boss Phil Spencer.

The US Supreme Court has agreed to review a lawsuit filed against Microsoft that alleges a defect in the Xbox scratched game discs, making them unplayable, The Associated Press reports.

The original suit, filed in 2007, was contested by Microsoft, according to GeekWire. Ever since then, it has passed through various US courts and the case is now being heard in the Supreme Court.

According to Microsoft, just 0.4% of users experienced the scratching issue which means it is not eligible for a class action lawsuit.

The case was initially dismissed as a class lawsuit — one that is made up of multiple people — meaning that each plaintiff would have to proceed on their own. This would have been difficult in a case that accused Microsoft of breaking game discs en masse.

The plaintiffs argued that it wasn’t the specific circumstances of each scratched disc that mattered, but the fact many people were complaining about it, according to GeekWire. The lawsuit was filed again in 2011 and has made it to the US Supreme Court via the appeals process.

According to GeekWire, the lawyers for the plaintiffs requested that the lawsuit was thrown out so that it could be appealed and then taken to the Supreme Court.

The outcome of the case is far from clear-cut and the US Supreme Court will initially be looking at whether it can review a case brought to it via fancy legal footwork. After that decision, the case will either be dismissed or it will progress.

According to the SCOTUSBlog, the court is looking at whether it can “review an order denying class certification after the named plaintiffs voluntarily dismiss their individual claims with prejudice.”

Business Insider has reached out to Microsoft to ask about the lawsuit. We will update the post when we hear back.

NOW WATCH: How Apple makes their Geniuses always seem so happy and helpful

NOW WATCH: Tech Insider videos

Want to read a more in-depth view on the trends influencing Australian business and the global economy? BI / Research is designed to help executives and industry leaders understand the major challenges and opportunities for industry, technology, strategy and the economy in the future. Sign up for free at research.businessinsider.com.au.

Tagged In

microsoft sai-us uk xbox