- Trump defence lawyer David Schoen warned impeachment could tear the country apart, like the Civil War.
- He essentially said the people who threatened political violence, and then committed political violence, might commit more political violence if displeased about the trial’s outcome.
- That’s an odd defence, given Trump is on trial for inciting a violent insurrection.
- This is an opinion column. The thoughts expressed are those of the author.
- Visit the Business section of Insider for more stories.
It was a defence by way of a veiled threat.
David Schoen, one of the lawyers defending twice-impeached former President Donald Trump said during an opening statement Tuesday: “This trial will tear this country apart, perhaps like we’ve only ever seen once in history.”
The “once in history” Schoen was almost certainly referring to was the Civil War, which resulted in upwards of 750,000 dead Americans.
It’s also a war where one side was fighting to preserve the institution of slavery, making it unimpeachably more evil than the other.
Schoen didn’t elaborate on his provocative point, so we don’t know on which side of the Union vs. Confederate fight he’d metaphorically place Trump supporters â€” even if some of them stormed the Capitol carrying the secessionists’ battle flag.
The insurrectionists also smeared faeces on the walls of the Capitol, threatened national security, and contributed to the killing of a police officer and injuries to at least 140.
Such trivialities don’t concern the 45th president’s lawyer. It’s the fact that the trial is happening at all that, to their minds, is a threat to the future of the Republic.
But Trump’s counsel unwittingly said the quiet part out loud.
Schoen â€” and many others arguing against the trial â€” are using the threat of more violence to demand no accountability for the previous violence.
In essence, this defence goes, a president who long fomented political violence among his supporters and then incited a group of those supporters to commit political violence, should not be held accountable because his supporters might commit more political violence if they’re displeased by the outcome of the trial.
This statement was coming from a defence lawyer, standing in the building that had been sacked by political violence, before a jury that was the target of that political violence.
For good measure, Schoen described Democrats’ efforts to hold Trump accountable as “blood sport.”
This isn’t the language of someone looking to turn down the temperature, it’s a threat.
Yes, it’s a show trial
Republicans have taken to calling this a “show trial,” which is both correct and totally wrong.
It’s wrong because “show trials” typically refer to proceedings rigged to produce certain guilty verdicts.
But it’s also a correct analogy, because most Senate Republicans have made it clear that they think the trial itself is illegitimate because the defendant is no longer in office. Their participation in the trial is purely ceremonial.
With acquittal all but guaranteed, the Republican argument against impeachment is that it’s merely an act of vengeance.
And it’s not so much Trump that they’re worried about, it’s the tens of millions who voted for him that would be “disenfranchised” by the trial.
This is all madness.
Voting for a losing candidate isn’t “disenfranchisement.”
But trying to strong arm elected officials and the vice president to overturn election results is. For that matter, so is inciting a violent mob to forcefully stop the certification of an election.
That’s what the trial is about. Not vengeance, but justice and accountability.
Schoen’s implication that holding a former president to the law for actions committed while still in office would lead to a Civil War-level of division would be asinine if it weren’t so dangerous.
Republicans with any sense of integrity should take the president’s lawyer’s words as a challenge, and at least admit that the trial itself isn’t an exercise in partisan hackery or a justification for further political violence.
Making Trump answer for his crimes against American democracy, in the form of a Senate trial, isn’t an act of violence. And shame on anyone who tries to pre-normalize further political violence in response to impeachment.
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.