Trump likes to take credit for new stock-market records -- so we graded his claims

All you need is a working Twitter account to know that President Donald Trump tries to take credit every time the stock market hits a new record high.

It’s a routine that has played out in 2017 as the S&P 500 has stretched well into the ninth year of a bull market that has brought it back to unprecedented highs.

So is Trump right?

Not most of the time. But there have been moments this year during which the so-called Trump trade, or the promise of a business-friendly change in the works, has been responsible for the gains. And we might be in the middle of one right now.

Then there was a long stretch when other factors were at play.

To best assess Trump’s fluctuating influence on stocks, we’ve looked at the S&P 500 on a periodic basis. After all, each timeframe we’ve selected has its own distinct bullish story, and put together they show how the stock market benchmark has gone from one high to the next — each time being pushed by a different component.

Methodology

At the beginning of each section is a chart showing the performance of an index of stocks tracking highly taxed companies, relative to the S&P 500. The measure is intended to serve as a proxy for the effect of Trump’s proposed policies on the benchmark, with the thinking being that a lowering of the corporate tax rate has long been seen as the campaign promise most likely to be passed.

If the high-tax index is outperforming, that implies a high degree of overall confidence in the Trump trade and therefore outsized influence being exerted on the S&P 500. If the gauge is underperforming (in negative territory), that implied a low degree of confidence and minimal influence.

And bear in mind that if the line veers into negative territory (which — spoiler alert — it does), that isn’t reflective of the broader stock market — it’s just the most actionable part of the Trump trade. The S&P 500 as a standalone entity has repeatedly hit new record highs all year long.

In the end, hopefully, we’ll have given you enough information to conclude for yourself whether Trump has, in fact, been as indispensable to the stock rally as he claims to be.

November 2016 -- February 2017: The best days of the Trump Trade.

Business Insider / Joe Ciolli, data from Bloomberg

Remember the first few months after the election? It seems like ages ago, and what a simpler time it was. The stock market ripped higher, off to its best-ever start to a new year, largely on the strength of the so-called Trump trade.

And we're not talking about the current iteration of the Trump trade. We mean the one taking place when all the promise of a newly elected but still out-of-office president's pro-business measures were still on the table, including lower corporate taxes, a repatriation tax holiday, massive infrastructure spending, financial deregulation, and a border adjustment tax.

The initial effect of that version of the Trump trade was undeniable. Every day it proved its mettle, as segments of the stock market ebbed and flowed with the latest headlines associated with each potential change.

Sure, earnings reports for the fourth quarter -- mostly released in January -- saw corporate profits expand. But it was at just half the rate we'd end up seeing later in 2017, rendering its ultimate effect relatively muted.

But you'll note that the Trump trade faded near the end of this period, providing an ominous sign of things to come.

Trump tweet of the period:

Number of stock-market closing records: 20

Was Trump responsible? Yes, definitely, although little did we know that the tax plan rollout he referenced in the above tweet was still months away (more on that below).

March 2017 -- August 2017: The Trump trade dies.

Business Insider / Joe Ciolli, data from Bloomberg

Look no further than the chart above to get an idea of when investors lost faith in Trump's proposed policies. Returns for the most highly taxed companies, infrastructure stocks, and financial firms either leveled off or dropped sharply, hurt by a lack of progress and worries stemming from a healthcare-bill defeat.

Yet the S&P 500 rally raged on, undeterred by the policy failings in Washington. A big part of this can be attributed to the so-called FANG group, consisting of Facebook, Amazon, Netflix and Google. If you expanded that to include other tech stocks like Apple and Microsoft, which were similarly unstoppable during the period, the collection represented the mega-cap backbone that allowed the market to continue its historic climb.

Also helping push stock indexes into the rarefied air was profit expansion. Mentioned in the section above as a minor positive catalyst, earnings growth absolutely exploded for the first- and second-quarter reporting periods, which largely occurred in April and July. The S&P 500 saw profit growth of 14% during the first three months of the year, and 11% for the second quarter, its best stretch since 2011.

Long story short, the market had a lot going for it during the period -- and none of it was built on Trump policy.

Trump tweet of the period:

(Note: None of his tweets included the phrase 'stock market' in the four-month period between March 2 and July 2.)

Number of stock market closing records: 18

Was Trump responsible? Not a chance.

August 2017 -- present: The Trump trade is ... back?

Business Insider / Joe Ciolli, data from Bloomberg

The timeframe since mid-August has been a mixed bag for the Trump trade. As you can see above, our indicator rallied sharply at the beginning of the period, largely on the back of the long-awaited Republican tax plan. The proposed measures focused on a corporate tax cut, as well as a one-time repatriation tax holiday. And since many of the companies that pay high taxes and stash the most cash overseas are the mega-cap tech stocks that wield huge influence over stock indexes, things started to look up.

Since late September, however, the Trump trade has started to flag once again as -- let me know if you've heard this before -- the S&P 500 hit a series of new records. This time around, the benchmark index was pushed to records by laggard sectors like energy and telecom, while tech faltered. The so-called market rotation that occurred showed once again that the S&P 500 has more tricks up its sleeve as it forges ahead into the ninth year of its bull market.

At present time, the jury is still out on the Trump trade's ongoing influence -- or lack thereof. After all, investors are starting to grapple with the prospect of a massive Federal Balance sheet unwind, as well as another set of quarterly corporate earnings.

Trump tweet of the period:

Number of stock market closing records: 13

Is Trump responsible? To be determined.

NOW WATCH: Money & Markets videos

Want to read a more in-depth view on the trends influencing Australian business and the global economy? BI / Research is designed to help executives and industry leaders understand the major challenges and opportunities for industry, technology, strategy and the economy in the future. Sign up for free at research.businessinsider.com.au.