- Donald Trump’s first priority when it comes to be Puerto Rico was reminding it of all the debt it owes Wall Street.
- This is rich considering how much Trump loves debt and bankruptcy.
- Puerto Rico’s debt problems have a long history involving several government missteps.
Reading tweets from President Donald Trump has become less an exercise in policy, and more a glimpse at what or who is driving the information the impressionable president is taking in.
That is how we know, based on a set of three Monday evening tweets about Puerto Rico, that Wall Street owns Trump right now.
Here are the tweets, in case you missed them:
“Texas & Florida are doing great but Puerto Rico, which was already suffering from broken infrastructure & massive debt, is in deep trouble…It’s old electrical grid, which was in terrible shape, was devastated. Much of the Island was destroyed, with billions of dollars…owed to Wall Street and the banks which, sadly, must be dealt with. Food, water and medical are top priorities – and doing well.
You’ll note that “top priorities” food and water were mentioned only after the president pointed out Puerto Rico’s massive debt, which is owned by a bunch of investors (especially the powerful hedge funds Trump bashed during his campaign).
There are some other non-debt problems Puerto Rico is facing that the president didn’t mention:
- Agriculture Secretary Carlos Flores Ortega says as much as 80% of the territory’s agriculture has been destroyed.
- Fitch research group BMI estimates the country’s GDP will take a -3.5% hit in 2017 and -2.1% in 2018.
- Catastrophe-modelling firm AIR Worldwide estimates up to $US85 billion in insured damage, to say nothing of uninsured damage.
Even though Trump opted not to tweet about those disastrous humanitarian and economic situations, the hedge funds, jockeying to get paid a piece of the $US70 billion in debt the territory owes, got a shout out. It seems that Wall Street’s priorities are at the top of the president’s mind right now.
Good for them. What they’re in the midst of is not a pretty fight, and it’s not an orderly fight. In fact it’s probably a fight that shouldn’t exist.
How Puerto Rico’s debt got here
The debt problems Trump tweeted about have a long and sordid history. Back in January Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin, formerly of investment bank Goldman Sachs, said during his confirmation testimony that his predecessor, Jack Lew, warned him to keep an eye on the Puerto Rico bankruptcy.
He said that while answering a question from Democratic Senator Bill Nelson of Florida, who bemoaned the “tragic situation” in Puerto Rico, which was caused “by quirks in the law that I do not understand how they got that way.”
“We have to have a plan,” Nelson said.
Of course, Mnuchin has no plan for Puerto Rico, despite his assurances at the time. There’s just a chaotic debt restructuring process and a bunch of rich, impatient Wall Streeters.
How the island got into this situation is an interesting story. It was a combination of Federal government negligence, a regressive tax structure, and strange legal footing that savvy investors were able to take advantage of.
Back in 2006, a tax break for manufacturers who set up shop on the island was allowed to expire. Employment fell around 10 percentage points between 2006 and 2010, according to a report by the New York Federal Reserve.
With revenue slowing, Puerto Rico decided to raise billions in debt to finance its government operations. Investors were willing to loan Puerto Rico money, despite the economic warning signs, because it offered high yields, and the island’s bonds had attractive tax breaks.
“It was politically favourable for the Commonwealth because they were able to do these things [like issuing bonds] and not put the burden on the residents,” David Fernandez, a public finance lawyer at Buchanan, Ingersoll & Rooney, told Business Insider back in 2015. “They kept doing it and doing it and the market kept buying and buying. Who wouldn’t do that?”
On top of that, business-friendly tax policies for some of the companies that remained on the island allowed multinational giants to pay tax rates of little more than 1%. Microsoft, for example, packages and ships its products from Puerto Rico. Thanks to what the government considered business-friendly policies, it enjoyed a 1.02% tax rate in 2011.
What you end up with is an island raising debt from investors while bringing in little revenue to pay them back.
The problems with this started to surface back in 2015, as did the fact that Puerto Rico didn’t have a great way to deal with them. You see, unlike, say, Detroit, Puerto Rico — a US territory — doesn’t have the option of using the bankruptcy process to discharge its debt.
So what we have is a chaotic government restructuring with Wall Street hedge funds handwringing to jump each other in line for payment. And those guys don’t complain quietly.
I hope you can see the irony of someone who has called himself the “King of debt” and has gone through bankruptcy four times touching on this topic. During Trump’s bankruptcy back in 2009, the one for Trump Entertainment — the company that held his Atlantic City casinos — Trump argued against a clean restructuring and for keeping debt on the books.
Then he and Ivanka basically sacked the company.
I guess he can’t sack Puerto Rico, so it will have to pay up.
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.