These Charts Show Why Apple Doesn't Need To Pay A Dividend

A lot of tech companies are sitting on mountains of cash.

Apple’s is the biggest — more than $100 billion in cash and marketable securities — and this week Fortune’s Apple reporter Adam Lashinsky (who just wrote an insider’s book on the company) reports that Apple is thinking about paying a dividend.

This would be Tim Cook’s doing — Steve Jobs thought returning cash to shareholders was a failure of imagination. Here’s a passage from Lashinsky’s book, Inside Apple: “He loathed stock buybacks, arguing, with good reason, that they are bribes to investors rather than good uses of capital … such topics were considered off the table with Jobs.”

Jobs may have had a point.

In the tech industry, paying a dividend is akin to admitting you’re no longer a high growth company.

That hasn’t always been the case — HP and Intel have both been paying dividends since the early 1990s, and both companies have shown fine growth since then.

But take a look at the stock performance of the last three big tech companies who decided to draw down their cash to pay a dividend. In each case, the stock price was flat or down before the dividend was declared.

Microsoft announced it would pay a dividend in January 2003 (the small blue Ds represent dividend payments). Before, its stock price had fallen significantly from a peak in 2000. The dividend does not seem to have helped:

Microsoft stock price pre and post dividend

Photo: Google Finance

Oracle followed suit in April 2009. Here, the dividend may actually have boosted the share price a bit.

oracle stock price pre post dividend

Photo: Google Finance

Now, take a look at Cisco, which announced dividends last March. Once again, the stock price has been flat (it’s too early to tell if the dividend will help raise it):

cisco stock price pre post dividend

Photo: Google Finance

Now, look at Apple’s stock performance over the last 10 years:

apple stock price last 10 years

Photo: Google Finance

You can use just about any other metric, too — revenues, profits, cash on hand. In each case, Apple is on a steep growth curve that’s amazing for a company its size. These other three companies are much flatter.

So why would Apple pay a dividend?

It’s certainly not to boost its share price.

Instead, it could be seen as a reward for the most loyal Apple shareholders. So far, the only way investors have made anything from Apple stock is by selling it. Returning cash to shareholders is a way of showing them value for sticking with Apple throughout its spectacular run — and giving them a little more incentive to keep holding.

NOW WATCH: Tech Insider videos

Want to read a more in-depth view on the trends influencing Australian business and the global economy? BI / Research is designed to help executives and industry leaders understand the major challenges and opportunities for industry, technology, strategy and the economy in the future. Sign up for free at research.businessinsider.com.au.