- Tesla says it will be profitable by the end of the year and won’t need to raise more cash. Many on Wall Street disagree.
- The company lost $US3.35 a share in the first three months of the year while burning through $US1.1 billion.
- Shares have lost 11% this year amid production delays, a spate of executive departures, and a bizarre conference call.
- Goldman Sachs analysts said last month that they thought Tesla would need to raise $US10 billion in the next 18 months. And this week, UBS analysts said they thought Tesla would need to raise additional capital before 2018 is out.
- Follow Tesla’s stock price in real-time here.
Tesla has been a stock market darling ever since it went public back in 2010. The stock is up more than 1,500% since the company’s initial public offering, and Elon Musk’s electric-car company is now worth more than the old-guard automakers Ford and Fiat Chrysler. It trails General Motors by just a few billion dollars.
That valuation has been attained despite consistent losses and problems with production. The company produced 101,312 vehicles last year, compared with Ford’s 2.59 million, while its newest car, the Model 3 sedan, grappled with production delays.
Now, with the company in a state of self-described “production hell,” analysts and investors are starting to ask serious questions about Tesla’s ability to fund its operations without raising additional capital. And with Tesla’s bonds taking a hit and markets jittery, the availability and cost of that capital is also in question.
Tesla is burning cash like crazy
The company burned through $US1.1 billion cash in the first quarter of 2018, regulatory filings show. That’s a slower burn than in previous quarters, when the quarterly cash burn hit $US1.4 billion, but it equates to a burn of $US7,430 every minute, Bloomberg calculated.
That left Tesla with $US2.7 billion cash on hand at the end of the quarter, much of which is tied up, according to analysts.
“Tesla has at least $US2.6 billion in obligations coming due (~$US750m in Gigafactory related accounting liabilities & ~$US1.8 billion in maturing debt),” the UBS analyst Colin Langan said in a note to clients Thursday. “Also, of its $US2.7 billion in cash, ~$US880 million is abroad (may be difficult to access) and customer deposits of $US1 billion will decline with higher deliveries.”
Tesla says it won’t need to raise cash, but Wall Street disagrees
“Tesla does not require an equity or debt raise this year, apart from standard credit lines,” the company said in an April filing. That sentiment was echoed by Musk a few days later, when he tweeted that “Tesla will be profitable & cash flow+ in Q3 & Q4, so obv no need to raise money.”
Wall Street disagrees.
The Goldman Sachs analyst David Tamberrino told clients earlier this month that Tesla may need $US10 billion in fresh funding within 18 months to stay alive.
“Between its current operations, anticipated new product spend, and incremental capacity additions, we see Tesla potentially requiring over $US10 billion in external capital raises and debt re-financing by 2020,” he said. “We believe this level of capital transactions may be funded through multiple avenues, including new bond issuance (secured and/or unsecured), convertible notes, and equity.”
And earlier this week, the UBS analyst Colin Langan said Tesla would need to raise capital in 2018.
“We forecast Tesla will need additional capital by Q418 to de-risk its balance sheet,” he said.
Tesla is already saddled with the most debt of any S&P 500 company, at least according to one measure. The company’s debt-to-EBITDA ratio sits at roughly 39 times, well above the next-closest firm in the benchmark index.
Its outstanding obligations total $US1.8 billion, and issuing more debt could be tricky going forward.
Tesla’s bond prices have fallen 9% this year, hitting an all-time low of 87.18 cents on the dollar in early April just after the credit-rating agency Moody’s downgraded both Tesla’s overall corporate rating and bond ratings, citing the “significant shortfall” in Model 3 production rates.
The latest yield on Tesla’s 2025 bonds is 7.61%, up from a low of 5.4% shortly after they were issued, suggesting that if Tesla were to raise money in the bond market today, it would be much more expensive than it was in the past.
When analysts on Tesla’s most recent earnings conference call tried to ask Musk about the possible need for a cash infusion, things only got worse.
‘The most unusual call I have experienced’
Tesla bosses including Musk, the CEO, joined sell-side analysts for a conference call following the company’s earnings report in May. These question-and-answer sessions are usually intended to give analysts an opportunity to get more context on the quarterly filings.
Musk answered Jonas’ question about the possibility of raising capital but had little patience for other questions about specific capital requirements.
“Excuse me, next,” he said, interrupting Antonio Sacconaghi of Bernstein. “Boring, bonehead questions are not cool. Next.”
The next question, from Joseph Spak of RBC Capital Markets, also prompted an interruption. “These questions are so dry. They’re killing me,” Musk said.
He then took seven questions from Galileo Russell, a self-proclaimed finance geek and retail investor whose “two biggest current fascinations are Tesla and bitcoin.” None of the questions were about Tesla’s financials.
Shares of Tesla sank 7% following the contentious call.
“I just left the call very frustrated,” Rebecca Lindland, an analyst at Kelley Blue Book, said afterward. “Elon, you’ve got to grow up. You’ve got to stop looking at shiny objects and you’ve got to get on track. You have to take analyst questions, adult analyst questions, not fanboys, not retail analysts.”
Bosses could be burning out amid ‘production hell’
Musk has repeatedly stated a production target of 5,000 Model 3s a week, a goal he most recently said the company hoped to reach by July. Based on the monthly reported numbers, however, Bloomberg estimates the latest output of Model 3s to be just 1,418 a week, less than half of the company’s goal. Tesla just flew in six planes full of robots to speed up battery production.
At least nine executives have departed Tesla this year. The company’s senior vice president of energy operations, Cal Lankton, was the latest to leave. He will be replaced by Sanjay Shah, who joins Tesla from Amazon. Additionally, Doug Field, a senior vice president of engineering, is on an indefinite leave of absence.
“Given the pace of departures of senior management in the past year and the stress placed on suppliers to meet production targets, we believe burnout is a legitimate concern,” the Oppenheimer analyst Colin Rusch said on Wednesday. “Indeed, burnout could prove a significant challenge over the short and medium term.”
Like most other sell-side analysts – who have a bullish average price target of $US317 for shares to Tesla – Oppenheimer says the company will most likely need a cash infusion.
“We believe investors expect that Tesla will need more capital especially given management’s acknowledgment of a China factory, another battery factory and the need for capacity to produce Model Y, the new Roadster as well as Semis,” Rusch said. “We would view an equity raise as a positive catalyst.”
Tesla is scheduled to report May vehicle deliveries alongside all other major automakers on Friday, when investors will be paying close attention to Model 3 numbers as well as any additional commentary from the company surrounding its impending cash crunch.
Do you work for Tesla or have other information to share?Get in touch with the reporter confidentially here.