White House press secretary Sean Spicer acknowledged Thursday that President Donald Trump has leveled attacks on the judiciary system — and that Judge Neil Gorsuch said he was “disheartened” and “demoralized” by attacks on the judiciary system.
But he repeatedly insisted that Gorsuch’s comments had nothing to do with Trump’s comments, leading to a series of heated back-and-forth exchanges with White House reporters about the issue.
Gorsuch, the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals judge who was nominated by Trump to the vacant Supreme Court seat, made the comments in question Wednesday during a meeting with Sen. Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut.
As Blumenthal told reporters, Gorsuch said he was “disheartened” by Trump’s attack on a federal judge. A representative for the Supreme Court nomination team confirmed the judge’s remarks to Business Insider on Wednesday.
“He said very specifically that they were demoralising and disheartening, and he characterised them very specifically that way,” Blumenthal said, according to CNN. “I said they were more than disheartening, and I said to him that he has an obligation to make his views clear to the American people, so they understand how abhorrent or unacceptable President Trump’s attacks on the judiciary are.”
But Trump took aim at Blumenthal in a Thursday tweet, saying the Connecticut Democrat “misrepresents” what Gorsuch said.
In a Thursday statement, Kelly Ayotte, the former Republican senator from New Hampshire who is leading the effort to help confirm Gorsuch, said the judge “made it very clear in all of his discussions with senators, including Sen. Blumenthal, that he could not comment on any specific cases and that judicial ethics prevent him from commenting on political matters.”
“He has also emphasised the importance of an independent judiciary, and while he made clear that he was not referring to any specific case, he said that he finds any criticism of a judge’s integrity and independence disheartening and demoralising,” she continued.
But elsewhere Thursday morning, another member of the Senate, Republican Ben Sasse of Nebraska, relayed similar remarks that Gorsuch made to him about Trump’s attacks on the judiciary.
Sasse told MSNBC that Gorsuch got “pretty passionate” when asked about Trump’s remarks, adding that any attack on “brothers or sisters of the robe” is an attack on all judges.
Taking aim at Blumenthal’s relaying of the comments, Spicer said Gorsuch was making “two, very complete, distinct arguments.”
Spicer said Gorsuch believed he “should not be commenting on a political matter or on specific things” but “on the whole, he doesn’t like attacks in general on the judiciary.”
“It was a very distinct argument that he was making,” Spicer said. “And that’s where I think we’ve got to be clear. And that’s what Sen. Ayotte was saying. Very, very different. … So you can’t then take that and equate it back to the specific.”
Asked specifically about Sasse’s comments, Spicer avoided answering.
Over the weekend, Trump fired off several tweets in which he called US District Judge James Robart — appointed by President George W. Bush — a “so-called” judge. Robart issued a nationwide stay on parts of Trump’s executive order temporarily banning travel into the US from seven majority-Muslim nations while the US reviews its vetting procedures.
Trump later suggested that, should any terrorist attacks occur while the stay was issued on the travel ban, the judge should be blamed. Critics of his remarks said the president was seeking to undermine the independence of the judiciary.
Spicer said Thursday that Trump has no regrets about his comments.
“I think the president’s comments speak for themselves,” he said. “No, he doesn’t have any regrets.”
The press secretary said Trump “is going to speak his mind” and said the press corps didn’t express “similar concern” when President Barack Obama made comments during a State of the Union address about a Supreme Court decision in the Citizens United case.
“He is free to speak his mind,” Spicer said of Trump. “Part of the reason the president got elected is because he speaks his mind.”
NOW WATCH: Watch protesters and Trump supporters get into a fiery argument on the National Mall right after the new president was sworn in
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.