Saudi Arabia has long trumped Russia in the Chinese oil market.
The Saudi share of Chinese crude imports at the beginning of the decade was around 20%, while Russia’s was below 7%, according to data cited by RBC Capital Markets.
But now the Russians are creeping in — and the Saudis are getting nervous.
“Russia is the biggest rival to the Saudis in the single-largest oil demand growth country in the world,” wrote RBC Capital Markets’ commodity strategist Michael Tran.
“The rising tide of Chinese growth has meant that notional volumes for both countries have increased in the years since, but Russia’s gains have been outsized,” he continued.
“The Kingdom now finds itself neck and neck with Moscow for the lead in Chinese market share, with both jostling in the 13-14% range, yet the momentum resides with the latter.”
Notably, the Saudis only managed to increase exports to China by about 120 kb/d over the last five years — a growth rate that was beaten by seven other countries including South Sudan and Colombia, according to figures cited by Tran.
Meanwhile, Russia increased exports by 550 kb/d in the same period.
Moreover, Russia even managed to overtake the Saudis as the biggest crude exporter to China during four months in 2015, continues Tran. Although this detail may not sound particularly impressive, it’s worth pointing out that the Saudis have lost the top spot only six times in the past five years.
Interestingly, part of Russia’s success in China has been attributed to its willingness to accept Chinese yuan denominated currency for their oil. (And not, as others have suggested, due to any sort of allegiance to the Sino-Russo friendship.)
On the flip side, “Saudi Arabia is losing its crown as its selling prices in Asia haven’t been attractive enough,” Gao Jian, an analyst at SCI International, a Shandong-based energy consultant, told Bloomberg back in June.
“If Saudi Arabia wants to recapture its number one ranking, it needs to accept the renminbi for oil payments instead of just the dollar,” Gordon Kwan, the Hong Kong-based head of regional oil and gas research at Nomura Holdings Inc., told Bloomberg back in June.
Although, of course, there are other things the Saudis could theoretically do to capture market share.
“Owning refineries in key demand regions guarantees market captivity,” writes Tran. “This has historically been part of the Saudi playbook and the recent reported interest in acquiring stakes in Chinese refineries is a strategic move that would guarantee the Kingdom a seat at the table in the preeminent region for demand growth.”
Basically, if the Saudis own the refineries, then their oil will be sold there.
In any case, the upshot for the overall oil market is that we’re probably not going to see Russian-Saudi coordination in the oil sector anytime soon, argues Tran.
“The recent meeting between the Russian government and its domestic oil company execs introduces a glimmer of promise for potential coordination with the Saudis and other OPEC countries, but the probability of a production cut remains low,” he wrote.
In sum, Russia has moved into China — and the Saudis aren’t loving it.
“Is there a sense of urgency from the Saudis? You bet,” notes Tran.
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.