Over the past five years, chef Robert Irvine has tried reviving 135 failing restaurants across America for Food Network show “Restaurant: Impossible,” now at the start of its thirteenth season.
Of these, 82, or 61%, have closed after their makeovers, according to the blog Food Network Gossip. But that’s actually not that bad of a statistic, since these restaurants were so poorly managed that Irvine and his team only took the job if there was essentially a 100% chance of imminent failure.
Irvine has noticed five recurring factors from his experience trying to whip these places back into shape. He shared with Business Insider his top five reasons why the majority of restaurants fail.
There are a lot of people out there who think they should open a restaurant simply because they know how to make a few great dishes.
'Potential restaurateurs do not realise or appreciate the specific set of demands that come along with owning and running a restaurant,' Irvine said. 'Once realised, it is often way too late.'
At this point, some owners bring in an industry veteran to help out. 'This can be effective, but it also adds more of a financial burden to the bottom line by bringing in someone who expects to be paid relative to their experience,' Irvine said.
'Unlike other businesses where you may find yourself managing just one group of people with one specific skill set, restaurants have a ton of moving parts requiring a diverse group of people with varying skills sets, talents, and personalities,' Irvine said.
He's found that the best restaurant managers he's worked with started at the bottom at a restaurant -- as a line cook, perhaps -- and worked their way up the chain of command.
'Managers who have walked a mile in the shoes of the people they are overseeing are more understanding, compassionate, and seek like-mindedness while providing insight into how best to relate to, approach, and motivate each member of their team,' Irvine said.
Irvine said that it's unfortunately a common occurrence for him to ask owners of a 'Restaurant: Impossible' location about their food and labour costs and how their revenue and profits stack up only to receive a dumbfounded look.
Another common mistake is that there's no system to ensure that numbers are kept up-to-date.
'One particular owner was so proud of himself for being able to report a 33% food cost until I dug a little deeper to see that his costs were based on old figures and that the cost of ingredients had risen significantly since he last did his calculations,' Irvine said.
'I don't typically give restaurants a second chance if I'm not given a great experience the first time around,' Irvine said.
Everything from how customers are greeted at the door to how they are handed their check will shape their first impression, 'and it is a well-known fact of business that customer retention is much more cost-effective than customer acquisition,' he explained.
And bad word -of-mouth will crush a restaurant quicker than ever before. 'As the digital era continues to grow and expand, review sites will, more and more, become the gatekeepers to customer acquisition,' Irvine said.
Most bad restaurants serve bad food. Wouldn't this seem like something the owners would care about?
'It's not from lack of personal taste or quality,' Irvine said. 'More often it's because of a breakdown in the chain of command and quality control. Day-in and day-out food preparation and presentation becomes routine -- sometimes almost a factory-like motion -- and can lead to steps being skipped and key ingredients missed over a period of time.'
'It's like de-evolution,' he explained. 'Very slowly your most popular dish can start to veer off its intended flavour profile and your cherished execution can stray from what is best for the end product.'
To maintain quality, the owners and chef need to keep the kitchen's standards high.
'It's key to consistently re-evaluate dishes and the quality control measures that were set into place,' Irvine said. 'I also insist on regular tastings before service to make sure that the quality of the product is top notch!'
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.