There’s been a lot of concern over the bond market recently.
The desire for yields to pick up, however, may have an unintended consequence, according to Robert Grossman at the credit rating agency Fitch.
“This year’s dramatic fall in yields on bonds issued by investment grade sovereigns has again raised the risk that a sudden interest rate rise could impose large market losses on fixed-income investors around the world,” said a note from Grossman and his team on Tuesday.
“A hypothetical rapid reversion of rates to 2011 levels for $US37.7 trillion ($AU49.56 trillion) worth of investment-grade sovereign bonds could drive market losses of as much as $US3.8 trillion ($AU5 trillion), according to our analysis.”
The price of bonds decrease as the yield goes up. The idea here then is that if the yield of these sovereign bonds increases dramatically, those that trade bonds would see price of these bonds decrease dramatically.
Bond yields are well below their average in 2011, so a sudden jump back to normal, or at least historical averages, would be a massive leap.
“Global composite yield curves, derived by Fitch from median yields of the 34 IG-rated countries (with at least $US50 billion [$AU65.72 billion] of outstanding debt) in July 2016 and July 2011, fell across all maturities over the past five years,” wrote Grossman.
“Median yields on 10-year securities are 270 basis points lower than they were in July 2011. At the shorter end of the curve, median yields on 1-year securities have fallen by 176 [basis points].”
Grossman and the Fitch team modelled the effect of a jump in yield on the price of bonds from 34 countries. The impact would hit Eurozone bond investors the most, with the jump from negative yields to heightened yields having a devastating effect. UK-based investors would also experience serious pain.
Now, as always, there are a few caveats here which even the Fitch team acknowledges.
“The pace of any potential global rate shock would be important,” said Grossman. “A more gradual rate rise, perhaps driven by a slow tightening of monetary conditions worldwide, would result in far less significant market losses for investors.”
Basically, it may be good for yields to go up as long as it happens slowly.