President Barack Obama has decided that the U.S. government will stop threatening criminal prosecution of families who try to pay ransom to win the release of American hostages held by militant groups overseas, the New York Times reported on Tuesday.
The president is due to make the announcement on Wednesday as his administration makes changes in policy on handling American hostages held by groups such as Islamic State, the Times reported, citing an unnamed senior administration official.
US officials have told the families of hostages taken by groups like Islamic State and al Qaeda that the American “no-concessions” policy prohibited them even from talking about possible terms of release and that families could face criminal charges for offering ransom.
The United States government’s staunch policy of not paying ransom to terrorists for hostages was questioned in the aftermath of the death of James Foley, a US journalist kidnapped in 2011 and killed by the Islamic State in August 2014.
The militants had demanded $US132 million from Foley’s family in November 2013, and his parents “were at the point of considering fundraising for a ransom,” Foley’s father said in a press conference following his son’s death.
Foley’s mother said the family was threatened by the government when administration officials caught wind of their plan to capitulate to ISIS’ demands. “We were told that raising ransom was illegal (and) we might be prosecuted,” she told CNN in September.
The government’s position at that time was clear:”We feel very strongly that it is not the right policy for governments to support the payment of ransom to terrorist organisations,” Ben Rhodes, deputy national security adviser to President Barack Obama, replied when asked whether the US needs to “rethink” its approach toward paying ransoms.
“In the long run, what that does is it provides additional funding to these terrorist organisations, which allows them to expand their operations. It incentivizes the kidnapping of foreigners in ways that we’ve seen, frankly, with organisations like ISIL and some al-Qaeda affiliates,” he said.
Not pursuing legal action against families who wish to raise these funds on their own, however, signals a shift in the government’s ransom policy.
It is unlikely that the government will loosen its policy of not paying terrorist organisations ransom directly, however. It is an open secret that many European governments pay for their hostages’ release, but they continue to deny it due to condemnation from the international community.
“The past few months have shown that the European policy (the U.K. excepted) of paying ransoms has driven a strong rift and created tensions in the transatlantic relation, which down the road harms the unity of our actions and diminishes the influence in North Africa, Sahel and the Middle East,” said Martin Michelot, a program and research officer at the German Marshall Fund of the United States.
But the family of James Foley — and other hostages killed at the hands of ISIS such as Steven Sotloff, David Haines, and Alan Henning whose governments have a strict no-ransom policy — demand that their politicians do more to protect them.
“I pray that our government will be willing to learn from the mistakes that were made,” Foley’s mother told CNN.
“The risk is becoming higher and higher,” she said, “and I really feel that our country let Jim down.”
Brett Logiurato contributed to this report.
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.