Nike's biggest sneaker advantage could become its biggest liability

  • Nike has been struggling to beat earnings expectations despite having more than 26,000 retail stores in North America.
  • The company is struggling with the digital revolution, something its analogue competitors are winning.
  • Digital upstart ‘click-to-brick’ brands are also eating into Nike’s profits.

The retail apocalypse and simultaneous digital revolution could be bad news for already-struggling Nike.

The Oregon-based sneaker giant has its shoes in more than 26,000 stores in North America alone, Jefferies estimates, and “is likely to see a multi-year painful unwind of lower orders, lower revs, and lower margins, as the digital revolution continues,” analyst Randal Konik said in a note Wednesday.

“With NKE perhaps the most recognisable brand, but also the most widely distributed brand in the analogue world, we believe this is pain the market under-appreciates and the company can’t fix easily.”

The bank reiterated its hold rating for shares of Nike with $US48 price target — 10% below where the stock was trading Tuesday morning, and a full 20% below Wall Street’s consensus target of $US58, according to Bloomberg.

Digital-only upshots are growing at a rapid pace, and pose an “invisible threat” to Nike’s business, Jefferies says.

Earlier this month, Jefferies analysed over 20 “brick-to-click” concepts that make up a grand total of $US3 billion in sales and $US1.5 billion in venture capital funding. These brands, like Fabletics, M. Gemi, and Outdoor Voices, are maximizing digital revenue with only a few physical stores — the opposite of Nike.

Incumbents are beating Nike as well. Germany-based Puma Tuesday morning reported a 16% jump in North American sales, fuelled by a new collection from Rihanna. Adidas, which reports next month, has seen a resurgence in demand for its retro sneaker designs.

“What concerns us about Adidas’s rise is consumers are purchasing across many of the brand’s platforms (e.g., Stan Smith, Superstar, Boost, NMD, EQT, Alphabounce, Tubular) which shows a real breadth of demand that is not going away,” Jefferies said. “In contrast, NKE’s category strength is becoming more narrow evidenced by a weakened Jordan franchise and less compelling running platforms.”

Shares of Nike are up 3.48% so far this year.

Business Insider Emails & Alerts

Site highlights each day to your inbox.

Follow Business Insider Australia on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Instagram.