- On Tuesday, New Yorkers voted to implement ranked-choice voting in primary and special elections, allowing them to rank their top five candidates in order of preference.
- Under a ranked-choice system, voters can rank up to five candidates in order of preference.
- Proponents of the system say it will eliminate the risks of “spoiler” candidates, discourage negative campaigning, and encourage more women and minority candidates to run, among other benefits.
- Critics say ranked-choice voting can cause confusion for voters and complicate vote tabulation, among other concerns.
- The adoption of ranked-choice voting in the biggest city in the country is a signal the system could catch on across America in coming years.
- Visit Business Insider’s homepage for more stories.
On Tuesday, New Yorkers passed a ballot measure implementing ranked-choice voting in primary and special elections – a dramatic shift that could have big implications for future elections.
Under a ranked-choice system, voters can rank up to five candidates in order of preference. If no single candidate wins a majority of the vote, the candidate with the least number of votes is eliminated and the votes for that person are redistributed to the voters’ next preferred candidate. That process of elimination continues until one candidate clinches a majority. Voters can rank anywhere between one and five candidates.
New York’s new voting system was approved with more than 73% of the vote and will be implemented in 2021. The adoption of ranked-choice voting in the biggest city in the country is a signal the system could catch on across America in coming years.
Proponents of ranked-choice voting cite a host of benefits the system offers. They argue the system will eliminate the risks of less popular “spoiler” candidates who benefit in crowded races when their opponents split the vote. And it will get rid of costly runoff elections, while encouraging more candidates to run and, as a result, more voters to get to the polls.
They also point to evidence that candidates will shy away from attacking their opponents, particularly those whose supporters they believe overlap with their own, because they’re motivated to appeal to a broad swath of the electorate. And they cite studies that show that more women and people of colour run under ranked-choice voting, in part because of the reduction in negative campaigning.
The system is already in use in nearly 20 other American cities, including San Francisco, Santa Fe, and Minneapolis. Maine is expanding ranked-choice voting to the 2020 presidential election. But New York is by far the most populous area to approve ranked-choice votingand will triple the number of people across the country who vote this way.
The plurality voting system, also called “first-past-the-post” or “winner takes all,” is used by most of the US. Ranked-choice voting is used in democratic elections around the world, including in Australia’s legislative elections, the UK’s mayoral elections, and Ireland’s parliamentary, presidential, and local elections.
AOC and Yang support ranked-choice voting
Some high-profile Democrats, including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and presidential candidate Andrew Yang, support ranked-choice voting. Ocasio-Cortez called it “pretty cool” in a tweet encouraging New Yorkers to vote in Tuesday’s elections. Yang said he wants to make the system “the norm” across America.
Just voted here in New York – Ranked Choice Voting is on the ballot! Ranked choice voting would let us express our true preferences and make our politics more dynamic and responsive. We should make it the norm throughout the country. ???????????? https://t.co/W55oRF7GXw pic.twitter.com/DY5QDZBJ2B
— Andrew Yang???? (@AndrewYang) November 5, 2019
2. Find out how you’re going to vote! This year we have 5 ballot proposals, including one on RANKED CHOICE VOTING which is pretty cool.
Here’s the NYT breakdown on the proposals. It includes their endorsements & rationale but of course vote as you wish: https://t.co/gETXK8RG8s
— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC) November 3, 2019
However, some Democrats and many Republicans take issue with ranked-choice voting. Critics say the system can confuse voters and make ballot counting more complicated. Some are concerned about “ballot exhaustion,” which occurs when voters’ don’t rank all of the candidates, including those that make it to the final round of ballot counting. This means they ultimately don’t have a voice in choosing between the two most popular candidates.
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.