Morgan Stanley is reportedly planning to fire up to 25% of its bond trading staff by the end of the year — and Wall Street analysts think it’s a great idea.
“The transition and reduction of capital from the FICC business could take time, but it is our view that if [Morgan Stanley] can articulate a clear path (with milestones) to that end state, it can begin to positively impact the valuation of MS shares,” UBS analyst Brennan Hawken said in a note on Monday.
He upgraded Morgan Stanley’s stock from $39 to $42 on the news.
Few investors expected the firm to aggressively restructure its FICC division, according to Hawken. If the reports of cuts are true, they would be more significant, and come sooner, than most investors expected, he said.
He estimated that a 1/4 reduction in FICC would add about 50 basis points to the firm’s return on equity (ROE), if the capital was returned to shareholders.
If it’s rolled into the equities or investment banking divisions, it could boost firm-wide ROE by 125 basis points. That bump would be even higher if the capital is deployed into the wealth management division, Hawken noted.
FICC businesses across Wall Street fared poorly in the third quarter, as debt traders began worrying about a potential economic slowdown. FICC revenues were down on average 18% year-on-year at all the major Wall Street banks. Front office headcount in fixed income was down too.
Morgan Stanley saw the biggest drop in bond trading revenue of all the major banks. It was down 42% year-on-year in the third quarter.
Last week, before news broke of the potential cuts, Deutsche Bank analyst Matt O’Connor lowered his fourth-quarter EPS estimate for Morgan Stanley by 14%, partly to reflect weaker fixed income trading.
Now, it looks as though management is responding.
The bank’s stock has jumped around 4% to about $35 since Monday’s news.
What do the cuts mean?
CLSA analyst Mike Mayo wrote in a Monday note that the cuts would have broad implications for the overall industry.
“It would seem to show a belief that trading could remain subdued for the foreseeable future,” Mayo wrote.
He estimated the cuts could save around $400-500 million, pretax, or 5-10% of overall compensation costs for the institutional securities group. The headcount reduction could amount to between 1,500 and 2,500 people.
Here’s how Morgan Stanley’s FICC and equities revenues have fared over the past decade compared with other banks, via Mayo’s note:
Morgan Stanley “probably won’t be the only investment bank to cut headcount,” Mayo wrote.
Of course, that would offer opportunities for other firms to step in and pick up share.
Goldman Sachs, for example, appears to holding firm in fixed income, despite slowing revenues. Goldman’s FICC trading revenues dropped 34% year-on-year in the third quarter.
“We are very committed to it because when we’re with clients, whether they are transacting on a particular day or not, it doesn’t matter to us. We know this service is important to them,” Goldman CFO Harvey Schwartz said at a conference last month.
“There are still going to be asset managers, there are still going to be bonds created, there are still going to be hedge funds in the world, there are still going to be clients globally who need to hedge, [there is] asset liability management,” he added.