McKinsey is famous for skimming the best from America’s elite universities, a practice that has become common at top consultancies. The pathway between Cambridge and the company was so well-trod that it’s been referred to as “McHarvard.”
It’s a deliberate choice of youth over experience; a strategy that McKinsey originated and made standard starting in the late ’50s, according to “The Firm,” a history of the company by Duff McDonald.
In 1953, McKinsey hired its first two top Harvard Business School (HBS) graduates, despite scepticism from more experienced consultants and legendary managing director Marvin Bower. It quickly became a core strategy.
“Between 1950 and 1959, as the proportion of consultants at the firm with MBAs climbed from 20 per cent to over 80 per cent, the median age of McKinsey consultants dropped by almost 10 years. Younger and hungrier — and a lot cheaper. Betting on potential has become one of McKinsey’s defining characteristics. The idea was simple: It was easier to mould a young mind than to change an older one. ‘Harvard …. doesn’t teach you accounting or finance,’ McKinsey Alum and convicted fraud Jeff Skilling once said. ‘They teach you how to be convincing.'”
The people who end up at McKinsey are often what are called “insecure overachievers.” They’re intensely ambitious — very bright people have always had everything mapped out. Then they have to leave school and enter the real world.
James Kwak, a former consultant, told McDonald, “The people at these schools are driven by desire for status and fear of failure. … When you graduate, you reach that terrifying point in your life when the next thing you do is not obvious, when there are a lot more choices than before. McKinsey makes it very easy for people whose primary goal is to keep their options open.”
Consultants get broad experience, a highly valuable line on their resume, and access to a vast network of clients and alumni once they finally figure out what exactly they want to do.
Hiring in this way seems so obvious and common now, it’s easy to forget how brilliant and revolutionary it was.
As McDonald puts it, “McKinsey had perfected personnel development. It hired the young and inexperienced for a pittance, then made its clients pay for their further education.”
They get C-suite executives of the world’s largest companies to trust their most secure data and most important business decisions to people decades their junior.
But by hiring from top-tier schools, having a notoriously rigorous hiring process, and putting consultants through brutal reviews that make sure only the best stay, McKinsey managed to create a perfect system.
It also helped turn the MBA into the highly prestigious and highly lucrative degree it is today.
More than 50 years after graduate business schools first appeared, they weren’t very well respected, according to McDonald. But McKinsey, by hiring so many MBAs and serving as a pipeline to prominent jobs elsewhere, legitimized the degree more than anyone else. As a result, HBS became a breeding ground for consultants.
By the mid 1960s, two of every five McKinsey consultants had gone to Harvard. In 1978, a quarter of all of the firm’s consultants were HBS grads. The company still hires extensively from the school.
Through its extensive alumni network, job placement expertise, and hiring practices, McKinsey has helped create the management and MBA elite that is so influential today.
By demonstrating that relatively cheaper youth can outperform expensive experience, they helped build a hiring culture that’s become a business standard.
It’s yet another example of the massive influence of the firm.