There was one event in the trial of “Making a Murderer” subject Steven Avery that shifted the proceedings in favour of the prosecution.
That’s the opinion of Dean Strang, one of the two defence attorneys who worked tirelessly to fight charges that Avery murdered photographer Teresa Halbach in 2005, as seen in Netflix’s true-crime documentary series. He says that moment was the admission of an FBI test that helped to discredit the defence’s argument that evidence had been planted to frame their client.
“I think it was a point at which momentum shifted,” Strang recalled in a new interview with the Daily Beast. “And maybe not fairly.”
A huge piece of the defence’s strategy was the theory that Manitowoc County police officers had planted Avery’s blood found in Halbach’s car. The defence cited a vial of Avery’s blood from his previous trial that appeared to be tampered with in an evidence locker.
In response, the prosecution brought in an FBI analyst who had tested the blood smears for EDTA, a chemical used to keep blood samples in liquid form (rather than coagulating) inside test tubes for use in future testing. Any presence of EDTA in the blood smears in Halbach’s car would prove that it came from a test tube and not from Avery himself bleeding.
“We had to have a hearing out of the jury’s presence to see if it was going to be admissible,” Strang said. “We had no chance at that point to do independent testing, or even to react terribly well to it because we’re being handed the report during trial and then, boom — [expert witness] Mark Lebow is on the stand the next morning.”
Lebow testified that the test did not detect EDTA, and so he believed the blood smears came directly from Avery’s body.
“[Co-counsel Jerry Buting], in front of the jury, then tried to establish that there were reasons to view the FBI’s hasty work as unreliable,” Strang said.
“Making a Murderer” raises questions about why the EDTA test by the FBI may not be reliable, as explained in detail here.
Avery is currently serving a life sentence for the murder. His appeals for a new trial have been rejected all the way up through the Wisconsin Supreme Court and he can no longer have a court-appointed attorney. As seen on “Making a Murderer,” Avery has requested the files for his case and is going it alone.
Strang has said there’s a possibility he and Buting will represent Avery again.
NOW WATCH: ‘House of Cards’ ran a realistic-looking political ad during the Republican presidential debate
NOW WATCH: Briefing videos
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.