- On Tuesday, the New York City Department of Health announced a public health emergency due to a 250-person measles outbreak in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.
- In January, another measles outbreak in the Pacific Northwest sickened at least 74 people.
- So far, nearly every child who has gotten ill is unvaccinated.
- Vaccination rates have plummeted in pockets of the Pacific Northwest in recent years, as lies about the dangers of vaccines have spread.
- The measles vaccine is safe for almost everyone and can prevent debilitating illness and death.
On April 9, the New York City Department of Health announced a public health emergency due to a measles outbreak in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. Since 2018, 250 people in the neighbourhood have been infected with the disease and that number is till increasing, according to the press release.
As a result, Williamsburg residents in specific zip codes must get the measles vaccines immediately if they are not already vaccinated. If they don’t do so within 48 hours and cannot prove vaccine exemption, the city has the right to fine them.
According to the New York Times, the majority of the 285 recent New York City measles cases have been concentrated in Hasidic communities in Williamsburg and Borough Park, where large groups of children are unvaccinated.
In January 2019, a similar public health emergency unfolded in the Pacific Northwest, when a measles outbreak sickened numerous people in Clark County, Washington, along with a man from the Seattle area and someone in Oregon. As of now, there are 74 confirmed cases in the region.
Both outbreaks were preventable.
In the Pacific Northwest, nearly all of the patients whose immunization status was confirmed didn’t get their measles vaccination. One child who contracted the measles had gotten a single dose of MMR vaccine (the full course is two shots), which is about 93% effective at preventing the measles.
It wasn’t always this way. State records in Washington show that during the 2004-05 school year, vaccination rates for kindergartners in Clark County were above 91%. But during the 2017-18 school year, Clark County youngsters entering kindergarten had an immunization rate of 76.5%.
In that 2004-05 school year, the vaccination rate was “getting close” to a threshold for herd immunity (around 95%), the Clark County public health director, Alan Melnick, told Business Insider.
Herd immunity is a level of vaccination at which people who can’t safely get vaccines (because they have HIV, cancer, or other conditions which make their immune systems more fragile) are protected. When enough people around them are immunized, they can live within a kind of protective tribe of disease-free people and are thus relatively “immune” to illnesses like measles.
Opposition to vaccines is generally based on junk science that has been endorsed by celebrities like Jenny McCarthy who, with Oprah Winfrey’s help, have falsely said there may be something dangerous about the measles vaccine. Melnick said one need look no further than his county’s official Facebook page to glimpse the rampant (and at times sophisticated) anti-vaccine propaganda spreading around the area.
Here are just a few of the ripest examples.
1. Before the introduction of measles vaccines in the early 1960s, just about every kid got the illness. Some anti-vaxxers wrongly assert that we’d all be healthier today if we continued to get measles. They have even suggested “measles parties.”
Getting the measles used to be a rite of passage for children – between 95% and 98% of children got it by their 18th birthday.
Before the vaccine was introduced, some parents tried to get their kids sick with the measles when they were young, since a case of the measles, like chicken pox or shingles, can be more severe when you’re an adult.
But even a run-of-the-mill measles case can be torturous. Melnick remembered having it as a young child.
“You’re miserable with measles. We’re talking about high fever. We’re talking about being sick for at least a week,” he said. “I remember being in bed for a long period of time with the blinds closed, because when you get those red eyes you get what’s called photophobia,” sensitivity to light.
Kids who are younger than 5 and adults over 20 are more likely to develop measles complications; some of the most common include ear infections and diarrhoea.
“Even without complications, it is not very pleasant,” Melnick said. “I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy.”
2. Unfortunately, a discredited doctor named Andrew Wakefield has led many people to mistakenly believe that there’s a link between autism and the measles vaccine.
One investigation suggested that part of Wakefield’s motivation was money.
Wakefield once “proposed starting a company that could reap huge returns from molecular viral diagnostic tests,” the journalist Brian Deer found in an investigation published in the BMJ in 2011. The scheme “predicted a turnover from Britain and America of up to £72.5m a year,” he said.
Measles killed more than 400 kids every year in the US before a vaccine was invented. By contrast, the most recent measles death in the US was one adult case in 2015.
The Centres for Disease Control and Prevention estimated that from 1994 to 2013, vaccines prevented more than 70,000 measles cases in the US, including over 8,800 hospitalizations and more than 57 deaths.
The last known measles death in the US was a Washington woman with a compromised immune system who died in 2015 from pneumonia that resulted from measles. She’s an example of one of the few people who shouldn’t get the vaccine, and of someone who’s at risk when there’s no herd immunity.
3. Anti-vaxxers sometimes suggest that because the measles is a live virus, the vaccine will make a person who gets the shot contagious. This is not true.
The measles vaccine is a weakened version of the live virus, and you’re not contagious after getting the shot. You may have some mild reactive symptoms like a sore arm, a rash at the injection site, or a slight fever, but this is your body building up its immunity.
Kids who get infected with the measles, on the other hand,can shed the virus for several weeks after their infection is over, thereby transmitting the illness to others. Infected people also may not know that they’re sick right away, since the initial symptoms are similar to the common cold (runny nose, cough, fever, and pink eyes).
“You can have those for several days before the rash starts, and you’re contagious for that period,” Melnick said.
The measles can also hang out in the air for two hours after a contagious person has left a room.
4. Vaccine opponents often argue that drug companies sell vaccines to make money. Actually, they’d make more money if they didn’t offer vaccines.
Vaccines, which cost about $US12 a pop, provide cheap protection against common illnesses. Unlike the drugs we take when something goes wrong, a vaccine dose (or two) usually lasts a lifetime.
That’s not a great moneymaking strategy for Big Pharma.
“By itself, Lipitor, an anticholesterol drug, brings in more revenue – about $US12 billion this year – than the entire vaccine market,” The Wall Street Journal reported in 2005.
Every dollar spent on the vaccine for measles, mumps, and rubella saves an estimated $US14 to $US26 in healthcare costs, including both the direct costs of caring for sick kids and the larger socioeconomic effects.
As Bill Gates likes to point out, vaccines provide a better return on investment than the stock market.
5. Some who rail against vaccines worry that a measles vaccine could cause kids to get more seizures. Again, not true: Febrile seizures are often triggered by fevers, and more measles cases means more fevers overall.
“Any child with a fever can get what’s called a febrile seizure,” Melnick said. These baby spasms, he added, are horrible to watch but typically benign.
“The disease causes a lot more fever than the vaccine ever does or ever will,” he said.
6. The same is true of encephalitis: It’s far more common to experience brain swelling because of the measles than the vaccine.
One in every 1,000 people who get the measles develops the brain-swelling condition.
Other severe (and rare) complications from measles can affect every organ system in the body.
Death from measles is rare, but problems can include pneumonia, croup, seizures, appendicitis, hepatitis, corneal scarring, blindness, and renal failure.
7. Melnick also said some anti-vaxxers express concerns that the measles vaccine contains mercury. It does not.
Some mercury is used as a preservative in flu vaccines, which may be the source of the confusion. But even so, it’s not a dangerous ingredient, and it isn’t in single-use vials.
“The mercury in there is not the kind that causes a neurologic problem,” Melnick said. “It’s not in the measles vaccine anyway.”
8. Some parents who don’t vaccinate their kids think measles wouldn’t be a problem if people just got enough vitamin A. This conflates the issue of malnutrition with vaccination.
Vitamin A deficiency makes it tougher for the body to fight all kinds of infections, including the measles. But vitamin A does not prevent measles.
Generally speaking, when your health is better and you have access to better food and nutrition, you’ll handle the measles better and have fewer complications. Even before a vaccine was developed, the death rate from measles in the US plummeted in the first half of the 20th century, to one death per 1,000 cases from 25 per 1,000. That’s because more people in the US were better fed and transitioned to less crowded living conditions.
But that doesn’t mean we’ve developed a natural immunity or that we should treat the measles as no big deal.
“People become complacent because they don’t realise how bad it can be,” Melnick said. “And that’s what scares me the most.”
9. Some anti-vaxxers wrongly suggest that people have died from the measles vaccine.
For this flawed argument, anti-vaxxers often point to a federal database called VAERS maintained by the CDC. However, the database makes clear that a report of a death after a vaccine administration doesn’t necessarily mean the vaccine is what caused the death.
It’s true, however, that there have been a few cases in which someone has died after getting a vaccine. The causes include severe allergic reactions (which can be treated by a clinician if a shot is administered in a clinic) and severe immunodeficiencies.
Many parents assert that not vaccinating their children is a personal matter. But vaccinations protect others from illness too, especially kids like Rhett Krawitt (shown below) who can’t get shots because their immune systems are too vulnerable.
“I respect people’s choices about what to do with their kids, but if someone’s kid gets sick and gets my kid sick, too, that’s a problem,” Carl Krawitt, Rhett’s father, told The New York Times in 2015, amid a measles outbreak in nearby Orange County.
10. Some parents of vaccinated kids in the Pacific Northwest say they might keep their youngsters home from school until the threat is over. That’s not really necessary, as the vaccine is 93% effective after the first dose and 97% after the second.
“About 3 out of 100 people who get two doses of MMR vaccine will get measles if exposed to the virus,” the CDC says, adding that those few cases will be milder and that those people are less likely to spread measles to other people.
Anti-vaxxers are a tiny but vocal minority.
In 2015, a Pew Research Center poll of 1,003 Americans found that 83% said they believe the measles vaccine is safe. In another poll, younger adults were more likely to say parents should get to choose whether their kids get immunized.
In other areas of the world, that’s not the case – families are clamoring to get their kids vaccinated.
Since 2000, measles-vaccine campaigns around the world have “contributed to an 87% decrease in reported measles incidence and an 84% reduction in estimated measles mortality” and prevented 20.4 million deaths, the CDC reported in 2017.