How bad is public transit in San Francisco? Bad enough that a huge industry of private transportation options have sprung up, from Uber and Lyft to newcomers like this week’s controversial startup du jour, Leap Transit — a high-end line of private buses equipped with WiFi, coffee, snacks, power outlets, and leather seats.
Leap’s slogan is “Your daily commute. Redesigned.” But San Francisco at large has backlashed: People see it as yet another way for startups to cater to the needs of those who can afford expensive private services.
In an effort to see what the fuss is about, I took a trip from the start of the Leap line, up at the La Luna Inn, all the way downtown. Here’s how the trip went.
Leap, which opened for business on Wednesday, runs 4 private buses (with one kept in the yard for emergencies) that run loops between San Francisco’s high-end Marina neighbourhood, where plenty of techie types live, and the city’s Financial District from 8am to 10am, and then the opposite way from 5pm to 8pm. Fares are a hefty $US6 each way (compared to $US2.25 for public transit), but less if you buy in bulk.
Leap stops are demarcated by blue-and-white poles with the Leap rabbit icon on top. I was the only one waiting at this first stop.
From the outside, Leap looks like your normal, everyday city bus, just in a bright shade of blue. In fact, three older tourists who were staying at the Inn asked if it was the bus that goes to Fisherman’s Wharf (it isn’t).
Before you get on the bus, you have to pull up the app, which provides a real-time arrival estimate as well as a number for how many seats were left. You can either check in with a QR code activate an “express” check-in option which uses Bluetooth to check you in automatically. I went with the second option.
I was sceptical, but as soon as I stepped on the bus, my phone buzzed, and Richard, the Leap “attendant” on duty, confirmed I was checked in. True to expectation, it was just me and Richard on this bus.
Given free rein to choose my seat, I sat down at what looked like the counter at your everyday coffee shop and sat on the leather stool, facing the window so I could watch the masses not on a private bus go by. On the other side of the bus were rows of black leather armchairs.
In the back of the bus was a more open seating area with benches and wood paneling.
Richard had a little bar counter where he could serve food and drink from a cooler and answer questions. A little Beats Audio boombox played indie rock from a Spotify playlist.
Striking up a conversation with Richard, I found out that it wasn’t usually this empty, and that the bus loop he had attended previously had as many as eight people on board.
Given that the buses can seat around 30 comfortably, that’s not exactly reassuring, but Richard said that the number has been growing every day. At one point, he had to go up front to confirm the route with the driver.
“We’re still working on routing stuff,” Richard said.
I ordered a Stumptown Cold Brew iced coffee from the Leap app, which automatically charged me the $US4.50 before Richard handed it to me. If I were hungrier, I could have also ordered a yogurt or energy bar.
Two more people got on at Gough and Greenwich, bringing us up to our peak ridership of three. One of them said he had tried Loop, a black car company with a similar service plan, and the other told me he only works from the office one day a week but takes Uber rides.
For his part, Richard says that most riders who take Leap complain about packed San Francisco city buses that get so full, they stop picking up passengers and just drive on by.
For both of my fellow riders, Leap offered a cheaper and more relaxed way to get where they’re going. They said they could see the service catching on.
“I think this is gonna get packed so fast,” one rider said.
The best thing I could say about Leap is that it’s boring: It’s designed to be frictionless, so you sit there and have a smooth ride and get off. It is, admittedly, a stark contrast from a crowded city bus.
Feedback from San Francisco at large hasn’t been so positive. When Leap launched, it became something of a local object of ridicule, just one more private transportation option for the 1% who can afford it but don’t already work at a company like Google that has its own buses. One headline on Leap Transit reads “San Francisco Gets The Ridiculous City Bus It Deserves.”
When a Leap bus broke down yesterday, on its second day of service, the schadenfreude ran deep.
Meanwhile, Leap — which doesn’t have a permit to operate as a transit service or use bus stops in the city — has had to fiddle with where it puts its stops to avoid stepping on toes and blocking traffic. In one case yesterday, Richard said, a homeowner got mad at a Leap bus for blocking her driveway, so the company had to move the stop. But then the bus stop was blocking a convenience store, and the driver made a complaint with Leap, forcing Leap to move the stop again.
Richard says a lot of complaints have come from people who live in the Marina who don’t want more traffic or more squealing brakes in their neighbourhood — a complaint he shrugs off, saying that traffic shouldn’t anything new.
“You already live in the city,” he says.
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.