I negotiated the price of everything I bought for a week -- and it worked half the time

You can save money on just about anything — you just have to ask for a lower price.

That’s what experts say, anyway.

While everyone knows that you should negotiate the price of a house or a car, Wisebread suggests
haggling on the price of everything from furniture to jewellery to food.

And according to Mint, asking for a discount works at least 50% of the time — if you do it right.

So I decided to spend a week trying to bargain down the price of every single thing that I bought. Here’s how it went.

Strategy #1: Asking for a discount when you buy more than one of an item.

Container store retailREUTERS/Andrew KellyAsking for a discount at The Container Store didn’t work.

My first attempt was at The Container Store, where I’d gone to purchase TSA-compliant toiletry bags.

My heart was beating faster than usual as I stood in line, and I felt incredibly nervous.

I’d never negotiated the price of anything before, and was sure that I was setting myself up for an awkward rejection.

When my turn came to check out, I asked the question that I’d been practicing in my head: “Is there any kind of discount that I can get, since I’m buying more than one of these?”

“Um, no,” the sales associate replied, and quickly started pitching me on the store’s loyalty program. Even though I wasn’t interested, I appreciated the way that she’d cushioned the blow, and happily paid full price for my bags.

Conclusion: Failure. This might work if you’re buying 20 bags. I was only buying two.

Strategy #2: Trying to get a sale price.

Antonia FarzanI successfully saved all of $US1.20.

My second attempt was at CVS. I needed thumbtacks, which cost all of $US4.

Still, I tried a strategy that a coworker had recommended: asking “These are 20% off, right?” and claiming I’d seen a sign advertising the sale price.

“It’s not coming up,” the woman at the register told me. “Where did you see the sign?”

I gestured vaguely in the direction of the office supplies.

She walked over to investigate, and I immediately regretted asking. Meanwhile, several people got behind me in line, adding to my sense of guilt.

A few minutes later, she came back, looking confused. “Where did you pick these up?” she asked me. I told her not to worry about it, not wanting to waste more of her time. Just then, she punched in the code for a coupon discount, bringing my total down by $US1.20. Success! I was so excited that I completely forgot that everyone in the store probably hated me.

Conclusion: This worked, but the guilt wasn’t worth the dollar and change that I saved.

Strategy #3: Complaining.

Antonia FarzanAfter spending half an hour in line at H&M, I didn’t feel bad about asking for a discount.

I felt justified in asking for a discount at H&M.

I’d waited in line for 30 minutes while the woman in front of me returned $US400 worth of clothes, and would have given up and left if I hadn’t really needed a pair of leggings to wear later that night.

“I know it’s not your fault at all, but I wasn’t expecting this to take half an hour,” I told the cashier. “I’m only buying one thing. Is there any way that I can get a dollar off?”

“Is there any damage to the item?” she asked. Not wanting to lie again, I told her, truthfully, that there wasn’t. “In that case, no,” she said, and rung me up. I left feeling slightly embarrassed: Was I really that desperate for an extra dollar?

Conclusion: Complaining about service at a hotel or restaurant might get you a discount, but it doesn’t work the same way in retail.

Strategy #4: Timing the negotiation.

I always pass the Union Square farmers’ market on my way to work in the morning, and sometimes end up buying a cookie or muffin for breakfast.

But on Wednesday, I decided to come back at the end of the day, when everyone would be packing up.

When I arrived at 6, the official closing time, lots of the vendors were already gone. Others were advertising end-of-the-day sales on their chalkboard signs.

At one stall where a man was packing up his truck, loaves of bread were selling for $US5 each. “Could I get one of these for $US3, since it’s the end of the day?” I asked him. He nodded and took my cash. “Take two, if you want.” There was no way that I’d be able to eat that amount of bread, but I thanked him anyway.

Conclusion: Success. I’ll definitely try this whenever I’m buying perishable food in the future.

Strategy #5: Asking for a price match.

When I came across a skirt that I liked on sale for $US44 at Banana Republic, I pulled out my phone and did some research. Sure enough, that same skirt was selling for $US18 online.

I showed my phone to the sales associate and asked if he could honour the lower price. After spending twenty minutes calling several different managers to ask what to do, he returned with an answer: I could have the skirt for $US18, but I’d have to order it online and select “Pick up in store” as the shipping option.

I would have been happy to do that since it meant saving close to $US30, but unfortunately my size wasn’t available online. Since I was using a gift card anyway, I sucked it up and paid the store price.

Conclusion: This method may work, but I don’t recommend trying it if you’re short on time.

Strategy #6: Offering to pay the full amount upfront.

Since I moved recently, I had to call and update the address on file for my pet insurance.

Typically, I pay $US32.77 a month, which comes to $US393.24 a year, to insure my cat, Rico.

Since I was on the on the phone anyway, I decided to ask if I could get a lowered price if I paid upfront for the full year.

“Yes!” the insurance agent told me.

My monthly payment had included a service fee of $US3, which added up to $US36 a year. She would waive that, bringing my annual payment down to $US357.

Conclusion: I definitely plan to try this method for other monthly bills. Dropping several hundred dollars all at once isn’t easy, but if there’s a significant discount, it’s worth it.

Bargaining works, but it’s not always worth the effort.

Half my attempts to get a discount were successful — exactly what Mint predicted. And while I generally only saved a dollar or two at a time, that had a lot to do with the fact that I mostly made small purchases.

Still, I never got comfortable asking for lower prices. With small, independent businesses like the guy selling bread at the farmers’ market, I felt guilty knowing that I would have been willing to pay full price, and that I was cutting into their already-tight profit margins. At large chain stores, this wasn’t an issue, but I felt like I was wasting the cashier’s time and slowing down the line. So unless I’m buying something really big, like a couch, a new phone, or an insurance policy, I’m not going to try to negotiate.

NOW WATCH: 6 scientifically proven features men find attractive in women

NOW WATCH: Money & Markets videos

Want to read a more in-depth view on the trends influencing Australian business and the global economy? BI / Research is designed to help executives and industry leaders understand the major challenges and opportunities for industry, technology, strategy and the economy in the future. Sign up for free at research.businessinsider.com.au.