We Know ‘The Help’ Got It WRONG, Now Here Are 10 Other Ridiculously Inaccurate Movies That Re-Write History

The Help

History makes for great movies.  This is a given.

And while most historical films take a certain amount of licence with the truth, some retellings are more egregious than others.

Just take a look at “The Help.”

After a major press push and the success of the best-selling novel on which it was based, it looked as though the Emma Stone-led film would be a summer hit.

But the rose-coloured look at history and the civil rights movement that “The Help” provides has come under harsh criticism.

And it isn’t alone.

We took a look at 10 of the most historically inaccurate movies that take surprising liberties with the stories from which they’re inspired.

Not so surprising? Mel Gibson earns three cameos on the list.

[slideshow]
[slide
permalink=”amadeus-1984-despite-what-the-film-implies-it-is-widely-believed-that-composer-antonio-salieri-did-not-plot-mozarts-death-1″
title=”Amadeus (1984): Despite what the film implies, it is widely believed that composer Antonio Salieri did NOT plot Mozart’s death.”
content=””
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e527662eab8ea444e00000f/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[slide
permalink=”pocahontas-1995-disneys-sugar-coated-film-animation-inaccurately-retells-the-story-of-pocahontas-as-a-love-story-with-british-settler-john-smith-while-pocahontas-is-said-to-have-helped-save-smiths-life-she-was-only-10-or-11-years-old-not-an-adult-as-the-film-depicts-oh-and-there-was-no-love-story-however-pocahontas-did-eventually-marry-another-british-settler-john-rolfe-2″
title=”Pocahontas (1995): Disney’s sugar-coated film animation inaccurately retells the story of Pocahontas as a love story with British settler John Smith. While Pocahontas is said to have helped save Smith’s life, she was only 10 or 11-years-old (not an adult as the film depicts). Oh, and there was no “love story.” However, Pocahontas did eventually marry another British settler, John Rolfe.”
content=””
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e525de369bedddf3600003c/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[slide
permalink=”braveheart-1995-the-films-hero-william-wallace-was-far-from-a-poor-commoner-as-mel-gibson-would-have-you-believe-he-was-actually-a-knight-also-wallaces-father-was-not-killed-by-the-english-he-fought-on-their-side-in-exchange-for-political-favor-and-they-were-not-wearing-kilts-which-were-not-developed-until-three-centuries-later-3″
title=”Braveheart (1995): The film’s hero William Wallace was far from a poor commoner as Mel Gibson would have you believe — he was actually a knight. Also, Wallace’s father was not killed by the English (he fought on their side in exchange for political favour). And they were not wearing kilts, which were not developed until three centuries later.”
content=””
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e525dd069bedd0a3400003e/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[slide
permalink=”the-patriot-1998-the-films-main-character-benjamin-martin-played-by-mel-gibson-is-based-on-francis-swamp-fox-marion-unlike-gibsons-portrayal-however-marion-never-single-handedly-defeated-an-entire-british-defense-unit-but-he-was-responsible-for-the-killing-of-numerous-unarmed-cherokee-indians-and-raping-his-female-slaves-speaking-of-the-movie-was-also-criticized-for-ignoring-the-subject-of-slavery-and-attributing-certain-crimes-to-british-soldiers-that-never-happened-4″
title=”The Patriot (1998): The film’s main character Benjamin Martin, played by Mel Gibson, is based on Francis “Swamp Fox” Marion. Unlike Gibson’s portrayal however, Marion never single-handedly defeated an entire British defence unit — but he was responsible for the killing of numerous unarmed Cherokee Indians and raping his female slaves. Speaking of, the movie was also criticised for ignoring the subject of slavery and attributing certain crimes to British soldiers that never happened.”
content=””
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e525ec7eab8eaad6b000043/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[slide
permalink=”gladiator-2000-joaquin-phoenixs-commodus-was-actually-a-roman-emperor-who-was-respected-highly-by-the-senate-and-ruled-for-13-years-not-a-few-months-as-the-film-depicts-and-rather-than-falling-in-love-with-his-sister-lucilla-commodus-had-her-murdered-after-her-involvement-in-an-assassination-attempt-also-commodus-was-not-killed-in-the-arena-but-strangled-in-the-bath-by-a-wrestler-named-narcissus-5″
title=”Gladiator (2000): Joaquin Phoenix’s Commodus was actually a Roman Emperor who was respected highly by the Senate and ruled for 13 years (not a few months as the film depicts). And rather than falling in love with his sister Lucilla, Commodus had her murdered after her involvement in an assassination attempt. Also, Commodus was not killed in the arena but strangled in the bath by a wrestler named Narcissus.”
content=””
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e52609669bedd1437000048/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[slide
permalink=”pearl-harbor-2001-while-the-films-two-main-characters-are-based-on-george-welch-and-kenneth-m-taylor-us-army-air-corps-second-lieutenants-they-were-never-involved-in-a-love-triangle-and-did-not-go-on-the-doolittle-raid-in-addition-several-plot-components-long-distance-radio-transmissions-historical-props-misspellings-and-misused-terminology-would-not-have-existed-at-the-time-of-the-pearl-harbor-attack-6″
title=”Pearl Harbor (2001): While the film’s two main characters are based on George Welch and Kenneth M. Taylor, U.S. Army Air Corps Second Lieutenants, they were never involved in a love triangle and did not go on the Doolittle Raid. In addition, several plot components (long-distance radio transmissions, historical props, misspellings and misused terminology), would not have existed at the time of the Pearl Harbor attack.”
content=””
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e526a92eab8ea4d25000026/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[slide
permalink=”marie-antoinette-2006-the-sex-life-between-marie-antoinette-and-louis-xvi-and-the-subsequent-delay-to-produce-an-heir-is-a-central-focal-point-in-the-film-in-sofia-coppolas-version-louis-xvi-is-afraid-of-sex-in-reality-he-is-believed-to-have-had-a-medical-condition-which-was-later-fixed-via-operation-and-led-to-the-couple-conceiving-7″
title=”Marie Antoinette (2006): The sex life between Marie Antoinette and Louis XVI (and the subsequent delay to produce an heir) is a central focal-point in the film. In Sofia Coppola’s version, Louis XVI is afraid of sex — in reality, he is believed to have had a medical condition, which was later fixed via operation and led to the couple conceiving.”
content=””
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e52656f6bb3f74e39000001/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[slide
permalink=”apocalypto-2006-in-addition-to-the-social-structure-and-daily-life-of-the-mayan-people-being-portrayed-inaccurately-the-sun-god-kukulkan-to-whom-a-human-sacrifice-is-made-in-the-mel-gibson-directed-film-never-requested-nor-was-granted-such-8″
title=”Apocalypto (2006): In addition to the social structure and daily life of the Mayan people being portrayed inaccurately, the sun god Kukulkan, to whom a human sacrifice is made in the Mel Gibson-directed film, never requested (nor was granted) such.”
content=””
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e526dc4eab8eae227000041/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[slide
permalink=”elizabeth-the-golden-age-2007-in-addition-to-the-age-difference-between-cate-blanchett-36-and-queen-elizabeth-at-the-time-the-film-takes-place-52-the-queen-was-not-being-courted-by-such-men-as-ivan-the-terrible-who-was-actually-dead-then-and-instead-of-riding-in-full-armor-atop-a-white-horse-and-carrying-a-sword-the-queen-actually-rode-side-saddle-with-a-baton-9″
title=”Elizabeth: The Golden Age (2007): In addition to the age difference between Cate Blanchett (36) and Queen Elizabeth at the time the film takes place (52), the Queen was not being courted by such men as Ivan the Terrible (who was actually dead then) and instead of riding in full armour atop a white horse and carrying a sword, the Queen actually rode side saddle with a baton.”
content=””
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e52777069beddcb1e00000e/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[slide
permalink=”10000-bc-2008-where-to-beginwoolly-mammoths-did-not-help-to-build-pyramids-and-pyramids-were-not-actually-built-until-approximately-2500-bc-also-saber-tooted-tigers-shouldve-been-extinct-by-then-not-running-around-on-screen-10″
title=”10,000 B.C. (2008): Where to begin…woolly mammoths did not help to build pyramids and pyramids were not actually built until approximately 2,500 B.C. Also: saber-tooted tigers should’ve been extinct by then, not running around on-screen.”
content=””
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e5267cd69beddd56c00001f/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[slide
permalink=”before-it-was-a-controversy-causing-movie-it-was-a-best-selling-book-11″
title=”Before it was a controversy-causing movie, it was a best-selling book.”
content=”Click here to see 11 more books destined to become movies>>>
image=”http://static.businessinsider.com/image/4e4573a76bb3f76e3f000017/image.jpg”
caption=””
credit=””
credit_href=””
]
[/slideshow]