While the first problem may be a function of short-term market troubles, the second problem maybe the result of a structural shift, according to some investors.
“You’ve seem some of the California pensions, some New York pensions, and even today MetLife said they are walking out of a $1.8 billion hedge fund allocation,” Michael Gregory, chief investment officer at alternative investment firm Highland Capital Management, told Business Insider on Thursday.
Part of this is a function of the funds losing money, but Gregory and Highland’s cofounder and chief investment officer Mark Okada said a shift is taking place that is about more than just performance.
It comes down to two things: fees and flexibility.
Gregory highlighted the impact of fees on investors’ decisions.
“If you’re a [low volatility] equity fund and you’re generating mid- to high-single digits but charging 2% base fee and 20% carry, for a pension that’s not very attractive,” said Gregory.
Instead of paying high fees for a hedge fund, some individual and institutional investors are turning to liquid alternatives funds.
Liquid alt funds are similar to hedge funds in the sense that they try to outperform the broader market using strategies such as shorting and leverage, but they charge much lower fees, and allow investors to move money in and out of the fund on a daily basis.
Traditional hedge funds usually have “lock-up” periods that force investors to wait before withdrawing money.
Combine the lower fees with this flexibility and liquid alts can look like an enticing option.
“I see liquid alts disrupting the hedge fund industry over the next 15 years,” said Okada.
“We’ve been slowly spending a lot of time in this area and it’s a lot of hard work to educate investors, to have the right products, to get the risk management right, to get the distribution right, but you can have a transparent, low fee, daily liquidity mousetrap,” said Okada.
“If you can do that, and there are a lot of ifs, why you would ever go into a hedge fund vehicle?”
Gregory does think there is a time and a place for hedge funds, saying that sometimes a fund with a longer time horizon such as a hedge fund can work.
“We think that extrapolation of short periods and indicting the whole hedge fund industry is a bad move,” said Gregory.
Okada, however, summed up the shift using a comparison to another high profile, and successful, disrupter.
“I think this is disruptive, just like Uber is disruptive to cab drivers,” he said. “I think it is very disruptive and the establishment is pushing back.”