Why Buying Generic Apple Accessories Isn't Always A Good Idea

earpods vs generic iphone 5Generic iPhone Earpods vs. the real deal.

Photo: M. Woodruff/Business Insider

When I held my brand new iPhone 5 in an AT&T store back in December, I knew it was love at first sight. Then I forgot my charger at home for the first time.

The three perfectly good iPhone 4 chargers I had stashed in my desk were completely useless, and I went home with a dead phone for the first time ever.

The honeymoon phase was over.

Like the iPhone addict that I am, I knew I needed at least four backups in order to have a guaranteed source of power wherever I went. 

I couldn’t stomach dropping another $80 on chargers so soon after blowing $300 on a new phone, which is why I was thrilled to see an incredible Cost Brothers/Via Google Offers deal in January.

For $17 + $5 shipping, I got what looked like a pair of iPhone 5 Earpods, a 10-ft Lightning cable, a car charger and a wall charger (valued at $106 dollars).

I was only interested in the Earpods and charger (I don’t drive and my old wall chargers work just fine with the iPhone 5), but since both are worth $20 – $30 a piece, I figured it was still a good deal. I went for it. 

And I was deeply disappointed. 
When the package finally arrived a few weeks later, I immediately tried out the headphones. They looked almost identical to the real thing. 

But it didn’t take long to realise these were no Earpods. Everything I listen to sounds as if I’m at one end of a tin can and the music is on the other end of the world. Other people I know who purchased the same deal were similarly disappointed. 

After the earbuds, I took a closer look at the wall charger. According to the label, it’s made by a generic brand called “Happy China.” The same plug sells for a measly $1.52 on Amazon.com.  There are no manufacturers labelled on the other items in the bundle, so I couldn’t check.

Maybe all of the items in this kit would be valued at $106 if they were manufactured by Apple, but as far as I can tell, these are exactly the kind of generic knockoffs tech experts predicted would flood the market soon after the new phone was released. I’ve had $5 earbuds from Big Lots that sound better than what Cost Brothers is selling.

Earlier today, I called up Cost Brothers as a regular customer with a complaint. A representative answered after the third ring, was perfectly polite and even offered to send a replacement pair of earbuds to me straight away. 

But when I called again later and asked to speak with a press representative, they were less than helpful. The person I spoke with (someone named Oscar) told me they “never said the accessories were from Apple” and promptly hung up on me. 

The problem, however, isn’t that the product isn’t Apple-made. It’s that they say it’s valued at $106 when it’s safe to say it’s not. I reached out to a press rep for Google Offers, which is still running the same deal through April, and am waiting to hear back.

The takeaway: If you’re looking for low-cost Apple accessories, just know what you’re getting yourself into. Most of those amazing deals are simply knockoffs. I did get an extra charger out of the deal, and it works fine as far as I can tell, but I can’t help but feel like I paid $22 for five items and got only one that’s of any use. I might as well have shelled out the $30 for a new charger from an actual Apple store and saved on shipping. 

NOW WATCH: Money & Markets videos

Want to read a more in-depth view on the trends influencing Australian business and the global economy? BI / Research is designed to help executives and industry leaders understand the major challenges and opportunities for industry, technology, strategy and the economy in the future. Sign up for free at research.businessinsider.com.au.