I went shopping at the grocery store voted the best on the West Coast and found the experience didn’t justify its shockingly high prices

Image
In order to see what made Gelson’s so special, I visited one. Irene Jiang / Business Insider

There are certain grocery stores, like objects, that spark joy.

Wegmans’ devoted following inspired me to journey to Brooklyn Navy Yard to check out its first New York City location. I was an instant convert. Others eschew the wonder of Wegmans for Southern grocery chain Publix. Some people even get married at Costco or smuggle Trader Joe’s products across international borders.

Gelson’s Markets, a regional chain based in southern California, was rated “Best in the West” by Consumer Reports this year and ranked fourth in the nation among 96 grocery store chains. Impossible Foods also chose Gelson’s to be the first grocery store to sell its plant-based burger.

In order to see what made Gelson’s so special, I paid a visit to a store location in Hollywood, California.


I arrived at Gelson’s on a Monday evening to a largely full parking lot.

Image

Near the entrance, there was a sign advertising the Impossible Burger.

Image

The first thing to greet me as I entered was a shelf of LaCroix.

Image

The interior was shiny and pretty, and the interior was full of that laid-back Los Angeles charm.

Image

Near the entrance, there was a small cafe area with books, magazines, and a bakery.

Image

The bakery is semi-separate from the grocery store and has its own name, Victor Benés.

Image

It was full of gorgeous cookies, pastries, and cakes.

Image

Just outside the bakery was a display showcasing products from a preserves and nut butters brand, Stonewall Kitchen.

Image

Its creamy peanut butter cost $US8 for a jar.

Image

Despite the full parking lot, I was surprised to find the store relatively empty.

Image

Next, I took a look at the meat section.

Image

On the shelves were packages of Gelson’s brand meat. At $US15 a pound, this New York strip steak was on the pricey side, but it looked pretty high-quality.

Image

Of course Gelson’s has a poké bar. What self-respecting high-end West Coast grocery store doesn’t?

Image

I briefly considered getting poké for dinner, but once I looked at the ingredients and price — $US18 a pound — I decided against it.

Image

Moreover, the raw seafood didn’t look too fresh. It was late in the day, though.

Image

There was also a fresh sushi section that was mostly empty.

Image

The fish in the case was not nearly as impressive as the colourful, shiny fish in Wegmans’ sushi case.

Image

Next, I headed over to the pickled foods, vegetarian options, and desserts fridges.

Image

These tiny glass pots of vanilla pudding cost $US3.50 each.

Image

Overall, there weren’t that many Gelson’s brand products. But most brands were local or organic, or some combination of the two.

Image

There was a large variety of plant-based meat alternatives.

Image

Sure, there wasn’t a whole lot of Impossible on the shelf. But it was still there, and it was there first.

Image

Next, I dipped into the wine, spirits, and beer section. There were a few restock carts sitting in the aisle.

Image

Most of the offerings were on the pricier side. Gelson’s brand wine was sold next to Francis Ford Coppola’s wine brand.

Image

However, I also found an incredible deal on apple pie-flavored moonshine. As a “Justified” lover and Margo Martindale fan, I had to try this.

Image

Mags Bennett, Martindale’s character on “Justified,” is known for her signature moonshine, which tastes like apple pie.


Like Wegmans, Gelson’s had a kombucha fridge. However, all these pre-bottled kombuchas were outside brands.

Image

When I looked up I noticed that the walls were lined with star-studded moments from Hollywood’s history.

Image

But the store didn’t feel quite as glamorous as it could have, despite a wood-paneled display fridge for fresh-cut cheeses.

Image

It was the first time I’d seen a wooden fridge, but this party platter inside looked less than festive.

Image

Overall, though, the fresh cheeses section seemed like a splurge that would be worth it.

Image

But the average shopper can’t live on splurges, and it was clear that even everyday products from normal grocery brands had some pretty significant markups. These Knorr chicken bouillon cubes cost $US2.79 a box at Gelson’s, but cost only $US0.98 on Amazon Fresh.

Image

Source: Amazon Fresh


$US9 for a rotisserie chicken wasn’t atrocious, but it was definitely on the high end of what I’d expect to pay.

Image

Next, I moved onto the dairy and eggs aisle.

Image

All the eggs on the shelf were pasture-raised, organic, free-range … you get the idea. A Gelson’s dozen cost $US4.50.

Image

At first, I balked at paying $US5 for discounted butter. But it was hand-rolled. Maybe it was worth the premium over the regular stuff.

Image

And honestly, most things at Gelson’s took me on the same buyer’s journey: this is too expensive, but wow, it’s really nice, maybe it’s worth the extra money.

Image

I feared my wallet might not make it out unscathed before I left the store.

Image

There was a fresh flowers and balloons section that sold everything from holiday wreaths to orchids.

Image

The produce section felt almost unbelievably overpriced. I could never justify paying $US7 for a mango, even if it was from Australia.

Image

However expensive it was, I had to admit that the produce section was fresh, colourful, and full of variety.

Image

Finally, I moved into the prepared foods section.

Image

There was a soup and salad bar separate from the hot foods section.

Image

There were also some prepackaged portions of deli foods and soups for a quick grab-and go.

Image

Here’s where Gelson’s really one-ups Wegmans. It not only has its own house brand of kombucha, but it also has its house brand kombucha on tap with reusable glass growlers.

Image

It was late and I hadn’t yet eaten, so I was looking forward to the hot and prepared foods section.

Image

There was a Wolfgang Puck Express with pizza and salads.

Image

Wolfgang Puck Express is a gourmet fast-casual and foodservice brand, but the food left in the case wasn’t too appetizing.

Image

The employees behind the counter were friendly and helpful. They offered me samples, and eventually I went with a superfood salad with Brussels sprouts and lemon vinaigrette.

Image

But that was partially because the hot food selection looked just kind of like mush.

Image

I left Gelson’s feeling disappointed. My visit didn’t spark the joy I had hoped, and I just didn’t understand how the chain had won the “Best in the West” award. I’ve been to other grocery stores on the West Coast that were far more impressive.

Image

Even though Gelson’s had high-quality products, I didn’t feel like most of them justified their even higher prices.