Warning: There are spoilers ahead if you’re not caught up with “Game of Thrones.”
Fans are in an absolute tizzy over Jon Snow’s fate on “Game of Thrones.”
At the end of season 5, Jon Snow was left for dead after a mutinous attack by his Night’s Watch brothers. Since then, fans have been in an inescapable debate of whether or not Jon Snow has been permanently killed off the HBO series.
But die hard fans refuse to believe the claim.
Theories of Jon’s survival have been circulating ever since 2011, when the last book, “A Dance With Dragons,” was released. When the show finally caught up to the books in season five, TV viewers joined in with wild speculation. We wrote up a lengthy overview explaining theories of how Snow could still be alive right after the season five finale. The short of the argument is that Melisandre, the red priestess, will probably revive Jon through a fire-magic ritual that has precedent in the series.
But at this point, fans are looking beyond the books for clues. Instead, they have turned to denouncing every statement and action made by those involved with the show’s production. These are the top six reasons fans are refusing to believe Jon Snow is totally dead.
1. The semantics game
When asked plainly if Harington was released from his contract, showrunner Dan Weiss told Entertainment Weekly: “Dead is dead.” The director of the finale episode, David Nutter, also told President Obama himself “Jon Snow is deader than dead.”
The latest insistence came from HBO programming president Michael Lombardo. “Dead is dead as dead as dead. He be dead. Yes. From everything I’ve seen, heard, read, Jon Snow is indeed dead,” he said.
This may have dispelled casual watchers from believing the hype, but the zealots have continued to brush these off as lame cover-up attempts. When you look at these quotes back to back, it’s almost comical how intent everyone is on using the words “dead” and “Jon Snow” in the same sentence.
This brings us to the semantics-based argument that devoted followers have begun circulating.
Sure. Jon Snow may very well be dead. BUT, he’s most likely going to be resurrected or reborn next season. Technically, HBO can put word out there that he’s “dead” without being deceptive.
Because, really, what else would HBO representatives say? “Well, you’ve figured it out! You’re right, he’s totally coming back.” Of course not. They have to try and maintain some semblance of mystery, however thinly veiled.
Just minutes after the season five finale, Entertainment Weekly ran an interview with Kit Harington, the actor who plays Jon Snow. When asked about the possibility that his character might not truly be dead, Harington was adamant. “They said, ‘Look, you’re gone, it’s done.’ If anything in the future is not like that, then I don’t know about it — it’s only in David and Dan and George’s heads. But I’ve been told I’m dead. I’m dead. I’m not coming back next season.”
Blowing right past the insistence that he is dead, readers latched onto the technicality of that last sentence. So Harington isn’t coming back next season. Does that mean he may come back the season after that? Some fans think so.
Kit Harington “i wont be in next season”Everyone “YOU KNOW NOTHING JON SNOW”
— SANDRA. (@sandruszeek) June 15, 2015
If anything, Harington’s comments just put internet detectives on alert for potential news of his appearance on set for the next season. “Game of Thrones” works on a tight schedule. Just weeks after the season five conclusion, actors and crew members began assembling in one of the set locations, Belfast.
2. Hiding in plain sight
Popular “Game of Thrones” news community Watchers on the Wall has reported multiple sightings of Harington among cast members in Northern Ireland. They referred to Jon’s return as “the worst-kept secret in Game of Thrones land.”
The argument can be made that he is merely on set to film a funeral scene, but this isn’t entirely convincing for one reason: Fans are reporting the Harington refuses to take photos with them.
Twitter user @ niamhweasley stumbled across Harington in a restaurant, and expressed her disappointment when he refused a photo.
Update we just met Kit Harington and Rose Leslie and I’m shaking
— Kingslayer (@niamhweasley) August 4, 2015
They’re so lovely but they can’t take photos and I’m sad
— Kingslayer (@niamhweasley) August 4, 2015
I met Kit Harington tonight & he was so humble&friendly&he pulled me closer to hm & i literally couldn’t be happier pic.twitter.com/ARswi3CbzH
— marika. (@greygardens) August 27, 2014
3. #HairWatch is in full effect
Harington’s precise location isn’t the only detail that fans are obsessing over. The length of his hair has become a focal point of many believers.
Kit Harrington was spotted in Belfast! Hair intact. Praise be to the old Gods and the new. #hairwatch
— Matthew Frazier (@Xer0Patience) July 21, 2015
4. A “quite spectacular” slip
Carice Van Houten, the actress who plays Melisandre and Jon Snow’s would-be savior, said in an interview after the finale aired “you feel that [Melisandre] is concentrating more and more towards Jon Snow … there are slight hints that something’s going to happen.” These words had a much more dramatic implication coming after Harington’s statements regarding the finality of his death.
Van Houten also teased that something “quite spectacular” was in the works for next season, but she wasn’t able to elaborate.
It feels as though Van Houten is referring to the hints fans have grabbed onto as a basis for their theories that Melisandre will be involved with Jon’s return from the dead. One commenter pointed out, “She’s not being terribly subtle.”
5. The telling history of San Diego Comic-Con
HBO / Helen Sloan
The final clue that fans have focused on came from the highly-anticipated “Game of Thrones” panel during the 2015 San Diego Comic-Con. These panels often feature both of the show’s creators, David Benioff and D.B. Weiss, as well as several prominent cast members who were killed off in the most recent season.
In 2013, the panel included Michelle Farley and Richard Madden; the actors who played Catelyn and Robb Stark, respectively. Their deaths at the Red Wedding massacre in season 3 were among the most shocking and game-changing of the entire series.
Then, in 2014, the fan favorites Rose Leslie (Ygritte) and Pedro Pascal (Oberyn Martell) were also present at Comic-Con. Ygritte was Jon Snow’s love interest, and had been killed during a battle at the Wall. Oberyn Martell had an iconic death against the Mountain. Both were on hand for the “Game of Thrones” panel to answer questions about their experiences on the show.
When the 2015 panel participants were announced, dedicated followers immediately noticed three major absences. Both show creators AND Kit Harington were missing from the line-up. This sparked plenty of conversation around the logic behind this decision, and whether it was a clear move on HBO’s part to avoid direct questioning about Jon from fans.
6. The incomplete “In Memoriam” toy collection
Mid-July, HBO announced a new collections of “Game of Thrones” character merchandise. The group of toys was dubbed: “Honor the Fallen: Game of Thrones™ In Memoriam.” The tribute includes the likes of Stannis Baratheon, Oberyn Martell, and Ned Stark.
Jon Snow was noticeably absent from the set.
More conspiracy conversations were sparked from this HBO announcement. Since many iconic characters were included, why not Jon? Perhaps it’s because his death is not as permanent as the those who were included.
The fact remains that, as far as anyone has been informed, only three individuals actually know the answer to this question. The author of the book series, George R.R. Martin, and the two creators of the HBO series David Benioff and D.B. Weiss. Martin has reportedly told Benioff and Weiss how the series ends, which means they should know Jon Snow’s true fate.
Until author George R.R. Martin publishes the sixth book, “The Winds of Winter,” dedicated followers of both the book series and the show are stuck in an frustrating but hope-filled purgatory.
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.