LONDON — Britain’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has found some peer-to-peer (P2P) lending platforms are using customer money to buy loans on rival platforms, rather than fund loans over their own platforms.
The FCA’s CEO Andrew Bailey told Business Insider: “What we’ve seen in a couple of firms in authorisations and supervisions is where one platform doesn’t have enough loans at present, they may take investors money and invest that in loans on another platform.”
No platforms involved in the practice were named and Bailey said: “I don’t think it’s very common, I think it’s quite an early spot from us.
“But there are a number of risks there. On the one hand, operationally, if there’s too much cross investment you’ve got a split cap investment trust issues. If one fails it could have knock-on effects throughout the other players. And then also investors may not understand the risks they are getting into because if they have chosen one platform because they like it they might find they’re exposed to other platforms.”
The FCA released a new report on regulation of P2P lenders and crowdfunding platforms on Friday suggesting tighter regulation of the P2P lending sector amid concerns that growing complexity is leading to risks that investors may not understand.
Bailey flagged the platform cross-selling risk as one of the regulator’s key concerns. The FCA said in Friday’s paper that one of the new rules it was proposing for the industry is “additional requirements or restrictions on cross-platform investment.”
P2P lending, also known as marketplace lending, was invented by British company Zopa in 2005. At its simplest, it is people using online platforms to lend directly to either other people or businesses, cutting out banks who normally sit in the middle. Investors get good rates of return and borrowers get quick access to cash.
Over £8.7 billion has been lent by P2P platforms in the UK since inception, according to AltFi data, with £3.4 billion of that in this year alone. Britain’s three biggest platforms — Zopa, Funding Circle, and RateSetter — have all lent over £1 billion each. But business models have become increasingly complex as the industry has evolved and the FCA is concerned that consumers are no longer fully aware of all the potential risks.
Disclosure has become a major issue in the industry after the CEO of LendingClub, Renaud Laplanche, was forced out in May, in part due to failure to properly flag his own investments in the platform.
Laplanche failed to disclose a personal interest in a fund that LendingClub was considering investing in and The Wall Street Journal reported he had invested millions in that fund so it could buy LendingClub’s loans, effectively to boost demand. The vehicle, which Bloomberg named as Cirrix Capital, bought $114.5 million worth of LendingClub loans in the first quarter of the year, according to a company filing.
Bailey told Business Insider in an interview on Friday that the “fast-moving, evolving” peer-to-peer lending industry poses “some quite big challenges in terms of transparency and fairness.”
- Credit Card Industry and Market
- Mobile Payment Technologies
- Mobile Payments Industry
- Mobile Payment Market, Trends and Adoption
- Credit Card Processing Industry
- List of Credit Card Processing Companies
- List of Credit Card Processing Networks
- List of Payment Gateway Providers
- M-Commerce: Mobile Shopping Trends
- E-Commerce Payment Technologies and Trends