- Far-right corners of the internet are baselessly claiming that two students who have been featured prominently since the Florida school shooting are actors, tied to the FBI, or both.
- The conspiracy has been promoted by the office of a Florida state lawmaker and President Donald Trump’s eldest son, Donald Trump Jr.
- Critics on both sides of the political aisle have blasted the rising trend, with Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida calling it the work of “a disgusting group of idiots.”
A widening conspiracy theory gaining traction on the far right baselessly claims that student survivors of a Florida school shooting who have made a series of TV appearances since last week’s massacre are actors, part of an FBI plot, or both.
The conspiracies have centered on David Hogg, who has been featured on CNN and CBS following the shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, which left 17 people dead and more than a dozen others injured; and Emma Gonzalez, who has spoken out about the need for politicians to enact gun-control legislation.
Hogg, a student journalist who says he interviewed classmates during the shooting, has since become one of the most prominent student voices, calling for stricter gun-control measures and characterising the response of politicians – and specifically President Donald Trump – as “disgusting.”
In his case, some far-right outlets have pointed to his father’s being a retired FBI agent to suggest something nefarious in the student’s frequent media appearances.
“Why would the child of an FBI agent be used as a pawn for anti-Trump rhetoric and anti-gun legislation?” Lucian Wintrich wrote on The Gateway Pundit, where he is the White House correspondent. “Because the FBI is only looking to curb YOUR Constitutional rights and INCREASE their power. We’ve seen similar moves by them many times over. This is just another disgusting example of it.”
On the website True Pundit, a story linking Hogg and the FBI ran under the headline “Outspoken Trump-Hating School Shooting Survivor is Son of FBI Agent; MSM Helps Prop Up Incompetent Bureau.”
“The kid who has been running his mouth about how Donald Trump and the GOP are teaming to help murder high school kids by upholding the Second Amendment is the son of an FBI agent,” an unnamed author wrote. “David Hogg is a school shooting survivor in Florida. At least that is what the mainstream media has told us. We wouldn’t be surprised by anything involving the FBI at this point.”
Pro-Trump accounts have shared the stories on Twitter and in some cases have thousands of retweets. The far-right One America News Network promoted a tweet suggesting Hogg may be “running cover for his dad who works as an FBI agent at the Miami field office.”
This is ‘the work of a disgusting group of idiots with no sense of decency’
Later on Tuesday, True Pundit posted another story under the headline “BUSTED: Trump-Hating School Shooting Survivor Visited CNN HQ Before the Shooting; Ranted Live on CNN After.”
The far-right publication published photos, claiming to be of Hogg, both at a CNN newsdesk and wearing a CNN T-shirt before last week’s shooting.
“But now we learn Hogg was hanging out at CNN headquarters in Atlanta, GA sometime Before the school shooting,” the unnamed author wrote. “Before the shooting. Posing behind an news anchor desk? Perhaps Hogg’s career dream is to sign on with the network – a young Jake Tapper – as he has portrayed himself since the deadly shooting that claimed 17 students as a ‘student journalist and entrepreneur.'”
Some people online pointed to footage of Hogg from a CBS Los Angeles newscast last summer, when he discussed how his friend got into a verbal altercation with a life guard, as proof that he was an actor who appears at various crises.
Others went after Gonzalez for being “coached” on how to respond to the incident.
Emma Gonzalez forgot ask why nothing was done after the authorities were called to the shooters house 39 times or why the FBI ignored the threat.
This chick was coached. Democrats used a innocent girl as a pawn.
— Kambree (@KamVTV) February 17, 2018
The conspiracies seemed to spill into the ranks of government, too.
Benjamin Kelly, an aide to Republican Florida state Rep. Shawn Harrison told the Tampa Bay TimesTuesday afternoon that both Hogg and Gonzalez “are not students here but actors that travel to various crisis when they happen.”
The prominence of the conspiracies led to Republican Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida publicly condemning those spreading the claims.
“Claiming some of the students on tv after #Parkland are actors is the work of a disgusting group of idiots with no sense of decency,” he tweeted. Hogg responded to Rubio’s tweet, thanking him for his comment.
The Florida House Speaker Richard Corcoran announced Kelly’s firing late Tuesday: “On behalf of the entire Florida House, I sincerely apologise to the students targeted and again commend them for their courage through this unspeakable tragedy,”Corcoran said.
By Tuesday evening, Kelly’s Twitter account had been deleted.
The focus on Hogg and Gonzalez comes in the wake of another popular right-wing theory related to the shooting – that the FBI missed warning signs about the Florida gunman because of its investigation into Russia’s interference in the 2016 US election and whether Trump’s campaign colluded with Moscow.
Trump claimed over the weekend that this may have been what led to the FBI failing to follow protocol when it received a tip about the shooter, 19-year-old Nikolas Cruz.
“Very sad that the FBI missed all of the many signals sent out by the Florida school shooter,” he wrote Saturday just before midnight. “This is not acceptable. They are spending too much time trying to prove Russian collusion with the Trump campaign – there is no collusion. Get back to the basics and make us all proud!”
The FBI has more than 35,000 employees and runs hundreds of investigations simultaneously, and a special counsel outside of the Justice Department is leading the Russia investigation. The bureau, however, acknowledged last week that it had failed in following up on a tip last month about the suspect in the Florida school shooting.
Trump has repeatedly accused leaders within the Justice Department and the FBI of being biased against him.
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.