- In recent years, Disney has started re-making many of its most beloved classic films into live-action movies.
- Using Rotten Tomatoes’ audience scores, Insider ranked all of Disney’s live-action remakes so far from worst to best.
- 2019’s “Aladdin” and “Lion King” are both audience favourites but the “Dumbo” remake from the same year was a flop with viewers.
- Critics enjoyed 2020’s “Mulan” but audiences didn’t.
- Visit Insider’s homepage for more stories.
Disney has remade a lot of classic movies over the past few years and it has a lot more in the works.
Many of these films have received mixed reviews and even though critics have both lauded and panned these remakes, audiences don’t always agree with the pros.
Read on for a ranking of all of Disney’s movie remakes so far, according to audience scores on Rotten Tomatoes.
Note: These scores are subject to change but were accurate at the time of publication.
In 1996, Academy Award-nominated actress Glenn Close led the remake of the 1961 animated film “101 Dalmatians.”
Audience Score: 41%
One user said that although the actress’s performance was the best part of the movie, the film itself was one of the “most boring, dull, annoying and most unnecessary live action remakes of all time.”
Colin Farrell, Danny DeVito, Eva Green, and Michael Keaton were part of the star-studded 2019 re-telling of “Dumbo” from director Tim Burton.
Audience Score: 46%
The live-action remake about the elephant with big ears who learns how to fly was not a hit with viewers, despite having a few new backstories and characters.
One reviewer wrote that the remake “really does just highlight how good the original animated film was in its sheer simplicity.”
A story of a heroic warrior, the “Mulan” (2020) remake won critics over, but not audiences.
Audience Score: 51%
Set in China, the live-action remake about a heroic girl who takes the place of her elderly father in war was not a hit with viewers, even though critics enjoyed the film.
Audiences found issues with the changes the remake made from the original. Some viewers also called out the lack of Chinese representation behind-the-scenes and lack of LGTBQ representation in the film itself.
The 2019 remake of “Lady and the Tramp” was just OK for most audiences.
Audience Score: 51%
This remake of the 1955 animated classic tells the story of two pups falling in love, and most critics and audiences both felt it was not bad, but not as great as the original.
Most reviewers said they liked the cast that voiced the pups, but that the film lost some magic by becoming live-action instead of animated.
Tim Burton helmed 2010’s “Alice on Wonderland” saw a teenage Alice return to Wonderland.
Audience Score: 55%
Mia Wasikowska, who played Alice, joined an all-star cast including Johnny Depp, Helena Bonham Carter, and Anne Hathaway, as she sought to overthrow the reign of the Red Queen.
Even though audience reviews were mixed on the character development and plotline, many viewers applauded the “visual splendor” of the film as well as its casting choices.
1994’s remake of “The Jungle Book” retold the story of a boy and his animal friends.
Audience Score: 55%
This remake of the jungle classic that tells Rudyard Kipling’s story was a bit of a flop for audiences, even though most critics enjoyed it.
Most reviewers concluded that this was a fairly OK adaptation that’s “sometimes thrilling, other times dull.”
2014’s “Maleficent” featured a completely different storyline from its animated predecessor “Sleeping Beauty” by portraying the iconic Disney villain as the protagonist.
Audience Score: 70%
Unlike the 1959 classic – which received an 80% from viewers on Rotten Tomatoes – the remake explored why Maleficent became a villain. It also dives into her relationship with Aurora.
It scored a 70% from audiences on Rotten Tomatoes, with many reviewers praising Jolie and her “extraordinary and charismatic performance that makes Maleficent a compelling character.”
The 2016 live-action “Pete’s Dragon” follows the story of an orphan named Pete and the friendship he cements with a dragon named Elliott.
Audience Score: 72%
Bryce Dallas Howard, Robert Redford, and Wes Bentley starred in the remake, which audiences mostly enjoyed.
Notably, the original “Pete’s Dragon” from 1977 earned just 60% from viewers, making this 2016 movie one of the rare Disney remakes that received a higher rating than the original film.
“Cinderella” (2015) re-tells the story of a girl who manages to escape the clutches of her evil stepmother and stepsisters to meet the prince of her dreams.
Audience Score: 78%
The film – which starred Lily James, Cate Blanchett, Richard Madden, and Helena Bonham Carter – was a hit with audiences, who ranked it higher than the original 1950 film, which got just 80%.
One reviewer wrote, “The live-action Cinderella grasps everything magnificent about the 1950s animated landmark and updates its presentation with grand effects and scale that’s both [as] magical and memorable as the original.”
The 2017 live-action “Beauty and the Beast” starred Emma Watson and Dan Stevens as the book lover and the prince-turned-beast who unexpectedly find romance in an enchanted castle.
Audience Score: 80%
The critical and box-office success of the 2017 live-action “Beauty and the Beast” likely led Disney to put a slew of other remakes in the pipeline.
As one viewer summarized the remake, “It has its problems and doesn’t live up to the animated classic, but Beauty and the Beast is incredibly entertaining and fun.”
The 2018 “Christopher Robin” film was a remake of the Winnie the Pooh films that follow Christopher Robin and his old friend, Winnie.
Audience score: 83%
Ewan McGregor played Christopher Robin and Jim Cummings voiced Winnie in the 2018 movie, which scored an 83% with audiences.
Although “Christopher Robin” is based on the “Winnie the Pooh” movies in general, arguably the most famous, “The Adventures of Winnie the Pooh” scored an 88% from audiences on Rotten Tomatoes.
The remake received high praise for being the ideal, heartwarming family movie.
“The Jungle Book” (2016) also re-tells the story of a young boy who’s raised in the jungle by a pack of wolves.
Audience Score: 86%
Audiences lauded the remake for its stunning CGI effects and the way it effortlessly blended the storyline of the 1967 film with Rudyard Kipling’s novel of the same name.
The remake scored higher than the original, which audiences gave 82%.
As one viewer wrote, “Once again, Disney doesn’t just remake it’s [sic] own film, it improves upon it. This is the best adaptation of this story to date.”
The 2019 re-imaging of “Lion King” tells the story of Simba’s journey back to Pride Rock after the death of his father, Mufasa.
Audience Score: 88%
With Donald Glover, Billy Eichner, Seth Rogen, and Beyoncé Knowles at its helm, the CGI-heavy film was a hit with audiences.
Even though many critics lambasted the 2019 re-telling, audiences widely enjoyed the film – but not as much as the original 1994 animated flick, which scored a 93% on Rotten Tomatoes.
As one audience member wrote, “Though enjoyable, with its breathtaking CGI and nostalgic moments, I’m afraid it was pointless to make, since it’s the perfect example of a shot-to-shot remake, copying exactly what the much superior original did. In short: I loved it, but could’ve been better.”
2019’s “Aladdin” tells the story of a street urchin who wins over Princess Jasmine with the help of a genie.
Audience Score: 94%
Will Smith, Mena Massoud, and Naomi Scott starred in the 2019 remake of this classic Disney film.
One user called the film an “undeniable spectacle,” writing, “Aladdin glistens with its extravagant visuals, musical numbers and solid performances from an up-and-coming cast and an always vibrant Will Smith steering the ship.”
- Read more: