If there’s a single, major criticism of Elon Musk, it’s that he presents himself as a hero of capitalism while investing in and running companies — Tesla, SpaceX, SolarCity — that wouldn’t exist without government funding and support.
“Elon Musk is addicted to government money!”
You hear it all the time. We heard it again on Wednesday when Jason Mattera — author of a book titled “Crapitalism: Liberals Who Make Millions Swiping Your Tax Dollars” and something of an aggressive, rising star in the world of conservative journalism and commentary — went on Fox News and listed Musk’s offenses.
The thing is, critics of Musk who claim the man is reliant on big government to keep his companies afloat aren’t wrong.
But the other thing is that Musk and his companies have never denied this.
When I was reporting on Tesla during some darks days for the startup back in 2008, the company made it abundantly clear that it needed to hit certain marks to obtain a Department of Energy loan guarantee and stay in business.
A few years later, Tesla warned in an SEC filing that its DOE guarantees represented a meaningful business risk, something that investors needed to be aware of. “We are dependent upon our ability to fully draw down on our loan facility from the United States Department of Energy, which may restrict our ability to conduct our business,” the company said in early 2010.
As for SpaceX — Musk has never pretended that there would be a SpaceX without NASA. The space agency is by far the fledgling private space company’s most important customer.
Mattera focuses on the fact that Tesla can sell zero emission credits in California to automakers who don’t produce enough zero-emission vehicles to satisfy the state’s requirements.
And of course SolarCity customers can claim tax credits when they use the company to provide solar panels. This mitigates some of the cost of installing the technology.
But Musk isn’t trying to hide this stuff. He just happens to have two companies that are in the green energy and green transportation spaces — businesses that the government is actively encouraging.
SpaceX, for its part, was in the right place at the right time to help NASA transition from the Space Shuttle to deep-space manned missions.
You bet we’re addicted to government money! Musk might say.
But he would then argue that the benefits of what Tesla, SpaceX, and SolarCity offer outweigh the cost to the taxpayer.
You can watch Mattera’s segment here and make up your own mind.
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.