Here’s how Tesla went from Elon Musk’s infamous $420 tweet to being worth almost $500 per share

Image
Tesla CEO Elon Musk. AP Photo/Jae C. Hong

I’ve been covering Tesla since 2007, and it’s hard to believe that it was just a year ago that CEO Elon Musk dispatched his now-infamous $US420 and “funding secured” tweet – and push to take the company private.

That decision wound up costing Tesla and Musk $US40 million in an SEC settlement, plus Musk’s chairmanship of the company.

But Tesla actually had bigger problems to deal with. Both 2018 and 2019 were tough, as the company struggled through production of the Model 3 sedan and worked feverishly to get a new factory up and running in China.

Somehow, it all came together in late 2019, just as Tesla revealed an absolutely bonkers vehicle, the long-awaited Cybertruck pickup.

Tesla’s stock rallied and rallied and then some. By the end of the year, $US420 was in the rearview mirror; by January 2020, a $US500 share price was in sight.

Here’s how it all happened:


On August 7, 2018, Musk was reportedly sitting in his car in Los Angeles when he tapped out the tweet heard ’round the world: “Am considering taking Tesla private at $US420. Funding secured.”

Image

Tesla shares were actually riding relatively high at the time: $US340. But they shot up to almost $US390 after Musk’s tweet, before settling at $US380.

Image

Musk’s take-private plan collapsed over the next few months. Tesla shares fell to $US250 and Musk would eventually face an SEC investigation into whether Musk misled investors. The settlement cost the CEO and the company $US40 million, and Musk agreed to restrict his Twitter habit while also forfeiting his chairman title at Tesla.

Image

With that catastrophe behind it, Tesla could get back to being a public company trying to hit sales targets from its Model 3 sedan.

Image

The results of that effort paid off in the third quarter, a historically money-losing Tesla swung to a profit. Shares rallied at the end of 2018, peaking above $US360.

Image

Tesla finished 2018 on a strong note, delivering almost 250,000 vehicles, a record. Fourth-quarter earnings also showed a profit, but it was lower than expected.

Image

The first half of 2019 was rough for Tesla bulls. The company sold a lot more vehicles and booked much higher revenue, but the losses were staggering. The stock plunged to $US190 by mid-year.

Image

The second half of 2019 saw Tesla return to profitability, and in October, an epic rally commenced. The carmaker’s execution had improved significantly, and Musk’s promise to bring a new factory in China online for 2020 had become a reality.

Image

The modest momentum that Tesla shares established in October went ballistic for the last two months of the year. The stock blasted through $US400 and then $US420 by Christmas, and in the first weeks of January, $US500 was in sight, with fourth-quarter earnings to come as a fresh dose of rocket fuel.

Image

The insane Tesla Cybertruck had also arrived, proving that Tesla was still able to blow minds with its visionary vehicles.

Image

Short-sellers had enjoyed high times in 2019, but they were crushed as the year closed out. With anywhere from a third to a fifth of Tesla’s total share float shorted, frantic covering propelled the rally to new levels.

Image

There were two big takeaways from Tesla’s wild 2018 and 2019 stock-market adventure.

Image

The first was that Tesla investing isn’t for the weak of knee. An ill-considered tweet from Musk and assorted growing pains on the manufacturing side cost bulls billions of dollars.

Image

The second is that in the auto industry, there is no magic formula. If you can build and sell vehicles on schedule and with discipline, revenue and profits should follow.

Image

Then you can move to scaling up, as Tesla now has in China, and begin to capture unmet demand.

Image

That’s how Tesla got from a $US420 tweet in August 2018 to a stock price much higher than that today, posting a 2,000% gain since 2010.

Image

In retrospect, maybe Musk’s idea of going private wasn’t so great! Better luck next time, Elon.

Image