El-Erian Gets Taken To Task For "Sugar High" View (VIDEO)

The rallying market has ignored Muhammad El-Erian’s previous “sugar high” comments, and it seems even better-than-expected August payrolls data wasn’t enough to make him budge.

Essentially, El-Erian argues that while the payrolls data improved (was less negative), it was still negative, thus a sustained recovery is far off. But he is taken to task in a somewhat heated exchange in the video below, starting at 1:20.

  • El Erian, 1:20: “These are worrisome numbers, because without credit, employment and wages are key to economic recovery. Empoyment is still a headwind and not a tailwind.”
  • Taking El-Erian to task, 2:30: “It would be quite unlikely, and in fact it would have been unprecedented, to go from -450 in the second quarter to job growth in the third, but if you look at the trajectory then I think it looked as well as it could.”

We think where Mr. El-Erian has been wrong so far is in missing the fact that where a market goes has a lot to do with where it is coming from. And historically, this market is still well off its highs, and still below where it was last September. Thus such a market doesn’t need “great” news. It just needs “better” news.

Latest payrolls data was exactly that, better.

NOW WATCH: Money & Markets videos

Want to read a more in-depth view on the trends influencing Australian business and the global economy? BI / Research is designed to help executives and industry leaders understand the major challenges and opportunities for industry, technology, strategy and the economy in the future. Sign up for free at research.businessinsider.com.au.