- Just as the pandemic’s economic fallout disproportionately hit low-income Americans and minorities, low-earning industries face a far more difficult return to pre-pandemic strength, said James Paulsen, chief strategist at The Leuthold Group.
- High-earning sectors’ unemployment rate jumped to just 12% and now sits at 5.5%. Yet low-earning industries saw their unemployment rate rocket to 23%, and it now stands at 9.6%.
- Outlined below are the four implications of such a bifurcated industrial recovery, according to Paulsen.
- Visit Business Insider’s homepage for more stories.
Certain pockets of the US economy are lagging the broad recovery. How they perform moving forward will determine whether the country can emerge fully recovered or split into two distinct economies, James Paulsen, chief investment strategist at The Leuthold Group, said in a recent client note.
Economists frequently described the virus’s economic fallout as giving way to a “K-shaped recovery,” where wealthier Americans quickly bounce back while lower-income groups and minorities struggle to return to pre-pandemic levels. A similar bifurcation across economic lines is also taking place across companies, according to Paulsen.
The pandemic’s fallout has been particularly concentrated in “social and lower-earning industries,” the strategist said. The trend is perhaps most evident in the labour market. Past recessions saw the unemployment rate for the lowest- and highest-earning sectors jump in tandem as damage was spread more evenly throughout the economy.
‘The unwinding of this bubble is going to be painful’: A renowned stock bear says today’s investors can expect negative returns for the next 12 years â€” and warns of a looming 66% stock plunge
The coronavirus crisis bucks the trend. The unemployment rate for low-earning industries rocketed to 23% from 3.5% in the early months of the pandemic, and has so far only recovered to 9.6%.
Yet high-earning industries saw their unemployment rate jump to 12% from 3%. Today their rate sits back at 5.5%, nearly touching pre-pandemic levels.
The separate recoveries taking place set the stage for an unusual return to normal, Paulsen said. Outlined below are the four implications of such a lopsided rebound, according to the strategist.
The clearest impact the split recovery has had is in revealing the country’s economic inequalities, Paulsen said. Just as poorer Americans faced the brunt of the health crisis, they shouldered the most economic pain and joblessness.
With low-earning industries unable to stage quick recoveries, unemployment will linger for far longer among affected companies.
“Alarming levels of homelessness and long lines for free-food distribution reflect the bifurcated nature of this economic crisis,” the strategist wrote.
Closing the gap
With the nation’s economic inequities forced into the spotlight, the country will enter a new period of expansion more aware than ever of its shortcomings, Paulsen said.
“Ending this pandemic will not only stop the horrific loss of life but will also help to modify growing evidence of economic inequalities,” he said.
Distribution of a coronavirus vaccine can help rapidly close the current gap between low- and high-earning sectors, Paulsen added.
A single-quarter collapse
The divergence of economic fallout helps explain the unusual nature of the 2020 recession and its brevity. Low-earning industries count for about 56% of total unemployment, but just 24% of total employment, according to Paulsen.
While economic pain continues to linger throughout the US, the second quarter of the year was the only one in which every part of the economy was impacted adversely. High-earning industries quickly rebounded in the third quarter, and much of the US already entered a new expansion.
“Because of the odd economic discrepancy caused by the pandemic, three-quarters of total U.S. employment, and probably a higher proportion of total aggregate demand, was only briefly (although profoundly) interrupted,” Paulsen said.
Yet 55% of unemployed Americans still face “extremely challenging conditions,” the strategist added. And while the most profitable industries have already exceeded pre-pandemic levels of output, low-income sectors are far from staging such a rebound.
Surviving the third wave
The division of economic damage sheds light on how the current third wave of infections will halt economic growth. Low-income industries will again face disproportionate harm, Paulsen said. Anti-social and high-earning industries will likely emerge fairly unscathed.
In all, overall economic growth through the end of the year should be “more resilient than expected,” but low-income sectors will continue to struggle on their way to a full recovery, the strategist said.
Now read more markets coverage from Markets Insider and Business Insider:
Investing pioneer Rob Arnott told us a near risk-free strategy for investors to win big from Tesla joining the S&P 500 â€” and explained how the company’s inclusion will lead index fund managers to ‘buy high and sell low’