How Bad Can It Get For AOL?

Tim Armstrong and Arianna Huffington of AOL barefoot

AOL stock is down almost 30%.

Its market cap is just $1.14 billion.

How low can it go?

Let’s assume what’s going on here is that investors do not believe in AOL CEO Tim Armstrong’s “media company” turnaround plan – that all they value is AOL’s subscription business.

Earthlink, an Internet access company that has turned itself into an annuity, is a decent proxy for what AOL’s subscription business could look like all on its own.

Earthlink’s marketcap is .88X revenue.

Annualized, AOL’s subscription revenues are about $800 million.  Apply the Earthlink multiple, and AOL’s subscription business contributes $700 million of market cap.

Note that this number doesn’t figure in AOL’s media business, at all. With help from a fairly sizeable brand – The Huffington Post – AOL’s display ad revenues reached $127 million this quarter – $500 million or so annualized. We think that business is growing fast enough to justify a 2X multiple. But let’s be conservative and give it a 1X.

Here’s the final maths: $500 million + $700 million = $1.2 billion.

So how much lower can AOL go? Not much before it starts to get outrageously cheap.

CORRECTION: An earlier update to this post said AOL finished down just 12% on the day, after reaching 30%. We reported that because its what Google Finance said. Google Finance was wrong.

NOW WATCH: Tech Insider videos

Want to read a more in-depth view on the trends influencing Australian business and the global economy? BI / Research is designed to help executives and industry leaders understand the major challenges and opportunities for industry, technology, strategy and the economy in the future. Sign up for free at research.businessinsider.com.au.

Tagged In

aol sai-us