MAD MEN V. REALITY: Compare Don Draper's Ads With Those That Actually Ran In The 1960s

Kodak-carousel-madmenSterling CooperSterling Cooper’s proposal for the Kodak slide projector.

For many, one of the most exciting things about Mad Men is seeing the creative process Don Draper and his team go through to come up with the ad campaigns that determine the very fate of Sterling Cooper & Partners.

Throughout the show’s six seasons, these campaigns have featured major brands ranging from Playtex to American Airlines.

But despite the best efforts of Don Draper, Peggy Olson, and the rest of the team, their ads are often not much better than the ads their fictional clients were running in real life during the 60s. Sometimes, in fact, Sterling Cooper’s ads were much worse.

Take a look, and judge for yourself…

Don Draper's Season 1 pitch for the Kodak Carousel remains one of the show's most poignant moments.

The real first ad for the Carousel, which debuted in 1962, wasn't as high-minded as Draper's, but it did explain what the product actually does.

Sterling Cooper's ad for Samsonite plays on the fact that nobody likes an empty suitcase.

Meanwhile, Samsonite's actual late-60s campaign was in colour and touted its luggage's ability to take a licking and keep on ticking.

Here's Sterling Cooper's concept ad for Mohawk Airlines. The agency ultimately dropped Mohawk for a chance at the American Airlines account.

A real Mohawk ad from 1968 put a greater emphasis on its attractive stewardesses.

When Sterling Cooper Draper Pryce pitched Jantzen, the clients felt the innuendo was too strong.

Jantzen's real ads were more modest. Here's one from 1960.

Sterling Cooper Draper Pryce's first hit campaign was for Glo-Coat. The boy in the ad is begging for someone to free him from the little jail cell he's made from a chair.

Glo-Coat's real ads were actually much, much cornier.

(video provider='youtube' id='koIY6yDIH0c' size='xlarge' align='center')

Here's a sketch Draper produced for Lucky Strike.

Lucky Strike's real ads featured former New York Giants star Frank Gifford from 1961 to 1962.

Sterling Cooper's attempt to help Playtex keep up with Maidenform asked women to decide whether they were a Jackie or a Marilyn.

Playtex would ultimately turn to the real Jane Russell, a popular actress of the day, to advertise its products.

Here's the ad Don made Conrad Hilton for Hilton Hotels. Hilton was not impressed.

Here's one of Hilton's actual ads, promoting its numerous locations across Europe.

Draper's ads for Playtex gloves were actually far superior to the real McCoy.


Life wanted something emphasising its health benefits instead of this Don Draper ad.

The brand really was pushing a health message at the time, as seen in this 1962 ad.

In Season 6, Peggy pitched Heinz executives on a Times Square billboard to draw a clear distinction between Heinz's one-of-a-kind Ketchup and rival brands' watered-down 'catsup.'

Sterling Cooper Draper wound up losing the pitch to JWT, but Heinz's real-life ad agency, DDB, was employing a similar strategy of differentiating Ketchup from catsup.

(video provider='youtube' id='XD2GWVLKw1A' size='xlarge' align='center')

It's easy to see why people from the Hawaii Sheraton interpreted Donald Draper's 'jumping-off point' sketch as being a little too morbid.

In real life, the Sheraton's competitor Hilton Hotels was sticking to the basics of fun in the sun.

Business Insider Emails & Alerts

Site highlights each day to your inbox.

Follow Business Insider Australia on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Instagram.