- Claire’s is being criticised for its policies on piercing non-consenting children’s ears.
- A former employee said she was told by a manager that she was expected to pierce the ears of protesting children even if the child needed to be physically restrained by a parent.
- Claire’s said in a statement that employees can refuse to pierce children’s ears, but it did not provide Business Insider with any guidelines as to how workers decide when they should or should not complete piercings.
- Visit BusinessInsider.com for more stories.
Claire’s, a retailer geared at young girls and teens, is being criticised for its murky ear-piercing policies.
On Sunday, Raylene Marks said in an open letter to Claire’s that she quit her job at a location near Edmonton, Alberta, after being told by her manager that she would be expected to pierce a child’s ears even if the child protested and had to be physically restrained.
Marks said she had “a couple ‘grey area’ piercings” where “the children resisted heavily, were pressured and intimidated by the parents into settling down, and the children weren’t happy with what had happened even after the earrings were in place and the standard lollipop had been dispensed.”
Marks said that recently she was supposed to pierce the ears of a 7-year-old girl who was resisting.
“She made it clear she no longer wanted to get her ears pierced,” Marks wrote. “She begged, over and over again, for Mum to please, just take her home. That child’s message was loud and clear to me: Do not touch my body, do not pierce my ears, I do not want to be here.”
Marks said that she wouldn’t help pierce the child’s ears and that ultimately the girl’s mother agreed to not go through with the piercing and took her daughter home.
Marks said that after the incident she spoke with her manager about what to do if the mother had insisted. According to Marks, her manager said she would have “no choice” but to pierce the child’s ears.
“I wanted to know how far we were supposed to take this policy of piercing non-consenting children,” Marks wrote. “‘So if a mother is physically restraining her daughter, holding her down and saying, “DO IT,” while that little girl cries and asks me not to, do I do the piercing?’ My manager did not hesitate to respond, ‘Yes, you do the piercing.'”
Marks said she gave her notice and soon after posted the open letter, which has sparked backlash against Claire’s online.
— Jillian Keenan (@JillianKeenan) April 8, 2019
This is awful. I have no problem with the parent giving consent to, say, a medical procedure where the child may not understand, but it a child understands that they are there to have holes poked in them for fashion and they don't want this, then it definitely should not happen
— Sophie Beth ????️???????????????????? (@sameoldbones) April 8, 2019
My wife and daughter will have nothing to do with @claires going forward. This is disgusting and I'm finding it hard to believe that the company has doubled-down on this terrible policy.https://t.co/xSjUmvVZv6
— Scott Dellinger (@scottdellinger) April 7, 2019
“Having worked at Claires, I support this fully,” one comment on Marks’ post said. The person added that piercing the ears of “older children who were prepared, or adults, was fine, but kids who didn’t want it, and usually was the parent who wanted it done, was heartbreaking, and I felt awful.”
“This teaches a child that their refusing consent to be touched means nothing,” another comment said. “Think of the precedent that sets for other contact in their lives. Thank you for doing what is right by that little girl and all the children that come in these stores.”
Claire’s told Business Insider in a statement that customer well-being is the company’s “main priority” and that all children’s piercings are carried out with the agreement of the legal guardian.
“In relation to the ear piercing incident involving the former employee Raylene Marks, we believe she acted appropriately and in line with our policy by refusing to do the piercing,” Claire’s said in a statement. “The policy is in place to ensure that if a child is distressed or resisting, Claire’s employees have the right to refuse to continue the piercing.”
Claire’s did not respond to Business Insider’s question about whether employees are given guidelines regarding when they should refuse to complete piercings.
“We are investigating the specific store instances she mentions, and will take appropriate corrective action,” the statement continued. “We will also be reviewing the policy to ensure that the intent is clear.”
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.