Saudi Arabia Won't Win This Oil Price Standoff

Citi is bullish on US shale.

A massive new (ungated) report, “The Rapid Rise of the United States as a Global Energy Superpower” from the bank’s macro analysts, suggests that the price of oil would have to dip to somewhere in the vicinity of $US50 a barrel to completely flatten US production growth.

From the outset of the report, this much is clear: Citi doesn’t believe that Saudi Arabia is going to be successful in bullying the US market by pushing prices down.

From the report: “…indications have emerged that suggest Saudi Arabia could look to allow prices to fall enough until US shale production is reined in. However, should such a circumstance arise, it looks like US shale/tight oil production growth could remain robust even in an environment of sustained lower oil prices, lower capex, and lower rig counts.”

The breakeven price for a well depends on a variety of factors, which the report goes through methodically (skip to page 31 for this). In places where the drilling infrastructure is mature and there’s not a lot of upfront capital costs in order to bring on a new well, breakeven prices are going to be a lot lower than in newer developing areas.

Here’s a key passage:

At what price might US shale production growth be meaningfully reined in?

Full-cycle capex for shale production includes land, infrastructure, and well costs (of which some 40-50% is from pumps, ~10-15% for drilling rigs) and operating costs. In mature plays where the land grab is over and infrastructure is available, the remaining capex required (“half-cycle costs”) to bring on an additional well is far lower than areas requiring “full-cycle” costs. Full-cycle costs might be as high as $US70-80/bbl WTI, but half-cycle costs could be as low as the high $US30s-range. Thus, those fringe and emerging areas requiring full-cycle capex could now face a reassessment, while established areas should continue drilling and growing output.

And here’s a group of charts showing the breakeven prices for well is various areas of the US shale production region:

Shale breakevensCitiCiti’s estimation of shale breakeven prices for various well scenarios

What if WTI prices go below $US70/barrel (it was below $US78 at last check)? Citi predicts a slowdown (about a 25% reduction in growth in 2015 and 50% in 2016), but not a halt, to US shale production.

What would it take to completely flatten production growth?

That “might require prices in the $US50 range in the short-term.”

Read the full Citi report here.

NOW WATCH: Money & Markets videos

Want to read a more in-depth view on the trends influencing Australian business and the global economy? BI / Research is designed to help executives and industry leaders understand the major challenges and opportunities for industry, technology, strategy and the economy in the future. Sign up for free at research.businessinsider.com.au.