China keeps applying the same measures to get its slumping economy moving again, but more and more of the same is now producing less and less of a result.
Recent Chinese economic data shows that stimulus measures applied since this summer’s roller coaster ride in the mainland’s stock market, precipitous dip in exports, and devaluation of the yuan are having little impact.
The patient is not responding to treatment.
Here’s a rundown of the data:
- Industrial output fell from 5.7% a year before, to 5.6%. Expectations were a 5.8% read.
- Infrastructure investment grew 13% from this time last year, but it grew 16% year on year in September.
- Property investment was -2.9% year over year in line with expectations.
- Housing starts fell -24.2% from the same time last year.
- Official data on consumption looks decent, led by an 11% jump in auto sales from the same time last year, though Bloomberg economist Tom Orlick notes that data from private retailers and creditors is more mixed.
China started easing its monetary policy to help spur growth last year. Traditionally that has meant a combination of rate cuts and credit-backed public investment from the government. Once the government gets going, usually the economy reacts within a few months, but economists like Wei Yao from Societe Generale say the data is telling us that China isn’t reacting as quickly as it used to.
“…the painfully lengthy policy lag now illustrates the diminishing return of traditional easing measures. Policymakers need to think beyond easing and start addressing the root causes, but we have not seen any indication of such a shift yet,” she wrote in a recent note.
China’s economy is going through a difficult period where policy makers need to strike a delicate balance. The country is moving from an economy based on investment to one based on consumer consumption. As it moves, though, the government wants to avoid some kind of credit event.
That means keeping old drivers of growth, like the property sector and massive state owned enterprises (SOEs), alive. Complicating this situation is the fact that these old growth drivers are carrying a ton of debt and are becoming sluggish, so the government has to use its resources to help them out.
That shows up in this month’s data dump, as most of the credit the government handed out to stimulate the economy got to SOEs, not private sector companies, according to Societe Generale.
Soon, though, the Chinese government is going to have to focus its efforts on reform rather than rescue. Deleveraging and restructuring these companies is the long term solution, but it’s a painful process in good economic times, never mind during a period of slow growth.
If the Chinese economy isn’t responding to short term solutions policymakers may have no choice but to go with long term solutions. Chinese SOEs have long enjoyed an implicit guarantee from the government that they will not fail, and that may have to end.
That’s when things will get hairy in China.