We Finally Found Someone With A Theory Of How The Pope's Resignation Could Influence The Market

Pope Benedict

Photo: AP

We were wondering if anyone was going to try to make a market call on the news that Pope Benedict is resigning/retiring/abdicating.And yes! We found one.

Bill Blaine, who writes a daily Blain’s Morning Porridge note for Mint Partners, argues that the Pope’s departure is bullish for Italian bonds, and Italy in general.

The argument is kind of twisted — and as he admits Dan Brownish — but it basically goes, that the Vatican still has a lot of power in Italy, and if there’s any chaos in Italy post-election, then a new young pope should have the vigor and energy to intervene and stabilise things.

We’re not endorsing the argument. But it is amusing.

Blaine writes:

And finally to the reason I think BTPs might be less vulnerable to electoral mischance than we fear. I’m thinking the new pope could be a very steadying influence…

 Replacing a deeply religious and conservative pope with a more secular player who will be more properly cogent of the Vatican’s perception of its place at the heart of Italy – especially at a time of rudderless politics – solves a number of issues.  And the timing could not be better. The month end Italian elections look irretrievably tied and a hopeless coalition is in prospect. And just as Italy wobbles, we’ll see the election of a popularly acclaimed younger pope in early March. Just in time to become a de-facto kingmaker.  That may make the prospect of Italian coalition confusion more bearable – and less to panic about. Monti’s showing in the election may be so poor as to rule him out of a future  unelected premiership, but others in his circle, like Passera, could find themselves elevated in a future “unity government” brokered by the church.  Why does it matter? Should Vatican politics impinge on BTP markets, Italian Stocks or Europe more broadly? Probably a good thing the wilder excesses of Italian politics are contained.. but.. really…

Don’t discount it.. the bottom investment line may be that a messy Italian election could be swiftly corrected through the mediation of the church – buy Italy on electoral dip?


NOW WATCH: Money & Markets videos

Want to read a more in-depth view on the trends influencing Australian business and the global economy? BI / Research is designed to help executives and industry leaders understand the major challenges and opportunities for industry, technology, strategy and the economy in the future. Sign up for free at research.businessinsider.com.au.