The Brussels attacks hint at a worrying 'iceberg' theory about terror networks in Europe

At least 28 people were reported killed and dozens more wounded after explosions ripped through Brussels airport and various metro stations across the city Tuesday morning.

The attacks came days Saleh Abdeslam, a suspect in last year’s Paris attacks, was arrested in Brussels, the capital of Belgium and de-facto captial of the European Union.

Clint Watts, a senior fellow at the George Washington University Center for Cyber and Homeland Security, noted on Tuesday that the Brussels attack are in line with an “iceberg” theory of terrorist plots.

That theory purports that, just as for every iceberg seen above water, the vast majority of its mass cannot be seen — “for every attacker, there are usually three to four additional people who helped facilitate the plot.”

“That the eight attackers in Paris used more explosive belts than ever before seen in the West suggests a sizeable European terrorist facilitation network,” Watts wrote for War on the Rocks in November.

He added: “The iceberg theory of terrorist plots suggests we should look for two, three, or possibly four dozen extremist facilitators and supporters between Syria and France. This same network is likely already supporting other attacks in the planning phase.”

Belgian officials have long been aware of the existence of an ISIS-linked terror cell in Brussels, believed to be centered in the district of Molenbeek. Belgium’s interior minister, Jan Jambon, has called Molenbeek “the capital of political Islam in continental Europe,” and multiple suspects have been arrested there in connection to the Paris attacks.

Outside of Belgium, at least 18 people have been detained across Europe since November for their alleged roles in the Paris attacks, The New York Times reported last weekend.

‘Considerable planning and coordination’

Tuesday’s attacks in Brussels bear a shocking similarity to the methods employed by ISIS in Paris on November 13, experts said. Those attacks are believed to have been coordinated by ISIS’ external operations wing, using multiple attacks across the city to overwhelm police and evade capture.

Just as the Paris attackers planned their assault for at least three months prior to the attack, experts believe the attacks that rocked Brussels on Tuesday morning were likely months in the making, the timing driven more by a desire to act before being disrupted than by revenge for Abdeslam’s arrest.

“Twin coordinated attacks on Belgian transport sites. Maybe revenge for Abdelslam, but planned and prepped ages ago,” ISIS expert Michael Weiss, author of ISIS: Inside the Army of Terror, tweeted on Tuesday.

Will McCants, author of The ISIS Apocalypse, agreed.

“Plots like this take weeks or months to put in motion,” McCants told Business Insider on Tuesday. “If the attackers are associates of Abdeslam, then they probably moved up the timetable of a preexisting plot to avoid capture.”

TwitterThe aftermath of the explosion inside the Brussels metro.

Terrorism expert Mia Bloom, professor of communication at Georgia State Univeristy and author of two books on terror-recruitment methods, told Business Insider that “a plot of this calibre requires considerable planning and coordination.”
“It is likely that Abdeslam’s cell has been plotting this prior to his arrest (there was a substantial arms cache found),” Bloom said.

She added: “Coordinated attacks (multiple attacks in the same location, happening around the same time) tend to require the most planning. While it’s impossible to know for certain, in my humble opinion, it is highly unlikely that these attacks took only a few days.”

Michael Horowitz, an associate professor of political science at the University of Pennsylvania, largely echoed this sentiment in a statement to Business Insider.

“I think that more than a retaliation, the attacks (likely planned months ago), were in reaction to it: The cell was likely concerned that Abdeslam would talk and his capture eventually lead to dismantling of their own cell.”

JM Berger, co-author of ISIS: The State of Terror, said in an email to Business Insider that while it’s “very early to draw any major conclusions,” it’s “certainly possible this attack had already been planned and the timetable was moved up after the arrest.”

A sophisticated ‘foreign infrastructure’

Whether a direct response to Abdeslam’s arrest or not, analysts say that the terrorist network’s ability to evade law enforcement after the Paris attacks long enough to plan and execute a major attack in the heart of the EU is testament to the deep terror networks jihadists have consolidated across Europe.

“The CT [counter-terrorism] federal police are actually very good,” Ben Taub, freelance contributor for the New Yorker on jihadism in Europe, tweeted on Tuesday. “It’s a numbers issue. Can’t keep up. Networks too deep.”

Matthew Levitt, director of the Stein Counterterrorism Program at the Washington Institute, corroborated Taub’s assessment: “
I spent last week in Belgium meeting CT officials (& taking metro) – they are only recently aware of the scope of their CT threats,” Levitt tweeted.
Middle East analyst Kyle Orton wrote on Twitter that if the attacks were planned by ISIS, it is “instructive about the nature of their foreign infrastructure.”

“If Brussels is a response to Abdeslam means: 1) this was already coming; 2) networks are very capable and widespread; 3) both.”

NOW WATCH: The ‘Zulu Cobra’ helicopter is one of the Marines’ most powerful weapons

NOW WATCH: Briefing videos

Business Insider Emails & Alerts

Site highlights each day to your inbox.

Follow Business Insider Australia on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Instagram.