I just dumped T-Mobile for AT&T

John legere t-mobile ceo announces iphone 5Steve Kovach/Business InsiderJohn Legere, the profane, disruptive CEO of T-Mobile.

Here’s a fact about me: I’m kind of cheap.

Which explains, in part, why I’ve been using T-Mobile as my wireless carrier for the past year. I have a family plan that includes myself, my mother, and my wife.

T-Mobile has the best prices in the wireless market in the U.S.

T-Mobile charged me $US80 for the account, then $US20 for my unlimited data plan, $US10 for my mother’s 1 GB of data, and $US10 for my wife’s 3 GB of data. That’s $US120 total, pre-tax.

But, with T-Mobile, you get what you pay for. And there are certain things you shouldn’t skimp on. Wireless connectivity is one of those things. As a result, I’ve dropped T-Mobile for AT&T.

From day one, our T-Mobile service was spotty.

After I signed everyone up, we went on a family vacation to Naples, Florida, which is not exactly an outpost. We had little to no service on T-Mobile at our hotel. We couldn’t text each other if we split up.

It wasn’t just Naples. I routinely lost service in buildings across the country.

In the kitchen of our office I had no signal. In the Target in my home town in Northern New Jersey I had no signal. My Mother was in a mall in New Jersey with a friend. They split up for a bit. He tried calling her 10 times but couldn’t get in touch because T-Mobile had no connection.

My wife and I recently drove to southwestern Pennsylvania with friends. While our friend on AT&T had strong LTE cell service during the car ride, we lost our connection for long stretches.

In our home, T-Mobile works well, but just 20 minutes from home, my wife lost her connection. As she reminded me — many times — if she got lost, she would be screwed. The phone is a GPS machine. If it has no internet connection and no ability to make calls, she’s going to have a hard time getting around.

In general, this is the story of T-Mobile. It works well outdoors in certain areas, like Manhattan, but if you venture just a few hours away, it’s a risk.

So, after more than a year of gentle and not so gentle prodding from my mother and my wife, I took the family to AT&T.

Why AT&T? I’ve used Verizon, AT&T, and T-Mobile in the past 5 years. The difference in network quality between AT&T and Verizon seems to be negligible at this point. Our T-Mobile phones work on AT&T, plus AT&T has good pricing.

While T-Mobile’s wireless service may not be all that great, its impact on the industry has been just the opposite.

AT&T has adopted some of the policies T-Mobile has pushed. It has roll-over data. It has the option to sign up for contract-free plans. Its prices are a tad bit lower. You can also say T-Mobile’s influence is what caused Verizon to kill all contracts for good.

AT&T is currently offering $US100 for service, plus $US15 per line, which is $US145 per month. It’s only 15 GB of data for the whole family, but that’s more than enough. We never went over 10 GB as a family on T-Mobile.

It’s $US25 more per month, which is $US300 extra per year. The cheapskate in me wants to stick with T-Mobile, since it works good enough for me.

But, strong wireless coverage is worth the premium price.

The only thing worse than no internet coverage is slow or spotty internet coverage. I would think I had coverage with T-Mobile, but in reality I wouldn’t and I would be refreshing Twitter, or trying to stream music. It would kill the battery on my phone and drive me crazy.

It’s worth an extra $US300 per year to have significantly better national phone coverage.

For anyone out there thinking of joining T-Mobile, I would say it’s just not worth the price.

NOW WATCH: This drummer created a whole song using only the sound of coins

NOW WATCH: Tech Insider videos

Want to read a more in-depth view on the trends influencing Australian business and the global economy? BI / Research is designed to help executives and industry leaders understand the major challenges and opportunities for industry, technology, strategy and the economy in the future. Sign up for free at research.businessinsider.com.au.

Tagged In

at&t sai-us t-mobile