Apple is famous for its commercials, which usually feature their flawless products against a white background.
But we rarely see Apple ads held up to a critical lens.
The critics were invited to an Apple event, where they ranked commercials from 1 to 4 stars, as they did for movies.
A 3-star rating, they explained, was the “critical turning point,” signaling their approval of a particular ad.
“A 4-star commercial would be: if you don’t own a TV set, buy it, leave it on at all times and watch it with your eyes open at all times,” said Siskel.
The first spot — which markets the Mac as an education tool — got 2.5 stars from Ebert but garnered a 4-star rating from Siskel, who called it his favourite.
See what else Siskel and Ebert had to say about Apple’s ads:
Business Insider Emails & Alerts
Site highlights each day to your inbox.